Title: Alternative Investment Solutions
1Alternative Investment Solutions
2Contents
- Hedge fund industry characteristics
- size, shape and implications
- risk, return and correlation role within a
traditional portfolio - Fund industry analysis
- basic strategy classifications and return sources
- drivers of opportunity and risk
- enhanced strategy classifications
- Research philosophy
- strategy research example
3Contents (Continued)
- Investment process
- strategy clusters, operational due diligence
cluster, asset allocation cluster and risk
management cluster - Client related topics
- mandate discussions
- issues surrounding transparency
- post 1998 environment
- regulatory environment
- industry maturation
- expectations and tolerances
- Conclusion
4Growth of the industry
The Hedge Fund industry continues to grow as more
investors allocate to the asset class
GROWTH OF HEDGE FUNDS (1990 - 2004)
1,000,000
As of Q3
889,838 (E)
900,000
817,492
800,000
700,000
622,304
600,000
536,060
46,588
487,580
ASSETS (USD MILLION)
456,430
500,000
75,084
456,430
374,770
99,436
367,560
400,000
46,544
20,353
256,720
300,000
54,847
185,750
4,406
167,790
200,000
91,431
95,720
57,407
14.698
58,370
100,000
(1,141)
38,190
36,918
27,861
8,463
0
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
Source Hedge Fund Research, Inc.
5Hedge fund industry
Raffaldini ppt.xlsPies?Chart 1
Hedge Funds capital flows are dynamic, and
require an understanding of strategies
Raffaldini ppt.xlsPies?Chart 2
Raffaldini ppt.xlsPies?Chart 1
COMPOSITION IN 1990
COMPOSITION IN 2004
Source Hedge Fund Research
Source Hedge Fund Research
6Hedge funds in a traditional portfolio
Whilst effect of adding hedge funds is to
increase return in long-term, emphasis is placed
on reducing volatility, due to hedge funds lack
of correlation with traditional investments
ANNUALISED RISK RETURN CHART (JANUARY 1990 -
DECEMBER 2003 INCLUSIVE)
Graph is grouped objects
Correlation of HFRI Fund of Funds Index - to MSCI
World 0.42 - to JP Morgan Global Bond Index
-0.07 - to 50 MSCI World, 50 JPM GBI 0.34
Source Bloomberg, Hedge Fund Research Inc.
7Upside participation and loss avoidance
Hedge funds seek to preserve capital during down
months for equities while attempting to benefit
from some of the gain in up months
PERFORMANCE COMPARISON OF THE HFRI FUND OF FUNDS
INDEX DURING POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE MONTHS OF THE
MSCI WORLD EQUITY INDEX JANUARY 1990 - DECEMBER
2003
Average monthly return during 70 negative months
for MSCI World
Average monthly return during 98 positive months
for MSCI World
Graph is grouped objects
Source Bloomberg, Hedge Fund Research Inc.
8Risk control in stress markets
Reduction in volatility is achieved because hedge
funds typically hedge against market risk
SEPTEMBER 2001 RETURNS
Graph is grouped objects, ungroup first to edit
Source Bloomberg, Hedge Fund Research Inc.
9Consistent performance
Excess return in hedge funds during this period
is achieved not by out-performing in good years,
but by preserving capital in bad years, resulting
in much lower volatility
Source Bloomberg, Hedge Fund Research Inc.
10How is this achieved?
Loss avoidance is everything
- Risk control is absolutely paramount. The
emphasis is on capital preservation, with loss
defined as loss of capital, not under-performance
of a benchmark - The key to understanding this is to appreciate
the compensation schedule for a hedge fund
manager - a management fee, usually around 1
- an incentive profit fee, usually around 20 of
net new high profits - The compensation schedule has a profound affect
in avoiding loss thereby creating a
non-symmetrical risk-return distribution - Furthermore, unlike relative return (benchmark
managers), hedge funds seek to produce absolute
return - In the event that market conditions are
difficult, they can simply raise cash and reduce
exposure unlike traditional strategies
11Basic classifications
The hedge fund industry has developed a diverse
set of strategies and styles to generate returns
Merger and Credit arbitrage spreads (Risk premia)
Company-specific research (Information)
Price Pattern (Behavior)
Liquidity provision (Risk premia)
12Drivers of risk and return
- Hedge funds attempt to create returns through
- Capturing market risk premia
- Exploiting market inefficiencies
- Risk premium exists to compensate participants
for assuming risk due to uncertainty - Markets are inefficient, generally in small ways
in many places - Information
- Market structure
- Liquidity
- Behavior
- Skilled operations with the proper tools may take
advantage of the opportunities
13Strategy classifications
Importance to delineate into the sub-strategy
level given differing sources of risk and return
drivers
- Fundamental Conservative
- Fundamental Aggressive
- Fundamental Short Bias
- Event Equity
- Opportunistic Trading
- Systematic Long / Short
- Systematic
- Discretionary Global Macro
- Discretionary Specialized
- Emerging Markets
- Fixed Income Arbitrage
- Statistical Arbitrage
- Convertible Bond Arbitrage
- Volatility Arbitrage
- Merger Arbitrage
- Credit Long / Short
- Distressed / High Yield
- Multi-Strategy
- Other RV / ED
Note These are the strategy groupings used by
Alternative Investment Solutions
14Research platform
Independent research platform integrates strategy
(top-down) and manager (bottom-up) analyses
15Investment process
StrategyClusters
Operational Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Undertakes research that generates
recommendations on managers within context of
peer group
Evaluates the various non-investment related risks
Generates recommendations on portfolio structure
Ensures risks within portfolios are understood,
intended and compensated
Manager Approval Committee1
Agrees upon a recommended list of managers for
portfolios
Investment Committees
Constructs portfolios based on specific risk and
return targets as it relates to the portfolio
mandate
Notes 1 Does not make portfolio-specific
decisions
16Strategy Cluster
Objective Undertakes research that generates
recommendations on managers within context of
peer group
- Research is underpinned by an in-depth
understanding of strategy drivers and manager
differentiation - Clusters allow global participation and
coordination of research effort, with resources
allocated along like skill sets grouping of
strategies - Thorough and efficient research designed to
provide forward-assessment of manager risk and
return expectations
17Responsibilities of the Strategy Clusters
Continuous review of dynamic factors underlying
each strategys risk and opportunity set
STRATEGY RESEARCH
SOURCING
Identify potential new managers
PRIORITIZING
Organize prospects in order of importance
MANAGER RESEARCH
Managers allocated to a lead SIO and/or IO
Initial Meeting
Establish general overview
Follow-up meetings
Gain comprehensive understanding
PEER ANALYSIS
Compare managers against industry peers on risk
and performance measures
MANAGER MONITORING
On-going manager monitoring to generate buy, hold
or sell recommendation
MANAGER RECOMMENDATIONS
Sponsored by CIO or SIO
StrategyClusters
Ops. Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Manager Approval Committee
Investment Committee
18Operational Due Diligence Cluster
Objective evaluates the various non-investment
related risks
Key points include
- Determine whether existing infrastructure enables
the manager to focus on generating returns - Assess the scalability of the operations relative
to the strategies employed - Establish a channel of communication between
Alternative Investment Solutions and the hedge
fund back office operations - Establish an understanding of information and
timelines expected
StrategyClusters
Ops. Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Manager Approval Committee
Investment Committee
19Responsibilities of the Operational Due Diligence
Cluster
RECEIVE FUND OVERVIEW
Receives overview of the manager from respective
strategy cluster
DUE DILIGENCE QUESTIONNAIRE
Send questionnaire to manager and review once
returned
SECURITY CHECKS
Instigate independent UBS security checks
Meet senior members of the managers logistics
teams
MANAGER MEETING
IOs generate and submit a report to the Manager
Approval Committee
REPORT GENERATION
Regular monitoring and discussions with the
manager
MONITORING
StrategyClusters
Ops. Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Manager Approval Committee
Investment Committee
20Manager Approval Committee
Objective agrees a recommended list of managers
for portfolios
- Draws on the output from the Strategy and
Operational Due Diligence Clusters - Committee comprises the Senior Investment
Officers of the group and is chaired by CIO - Committee meets formally on a monthly basis
- Discusses and debates occur informally on an
intra-month basis - Managers are approved by a two thirds majority
where a quorum is defined as a minimum of four
voting members - The Committee also determines managers to be
removed from the recommended list
StrategyClusters
Ops. Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Manager Approval Committee
Investment Committee
21Asset Allocation Cluster
Objective generates recommendations on portfolio
structure
- Iterative approach considering manager
availability, strategy research and
macro-economic views - Recommendations on strategy allocation framework
based on economic considerations, strategy
developments and risk - Rather than rely solely on traditional mean
variance optimization, strategy recommendations
also utilize other quantitative techniques - This avoids problems inherent in historical
modeling that occur when faced with
non-predictive factors
StrategyClusters
Ops. Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Manager Approval Committee
Investment Committee
22Responsibilities of the Asset Allocation Cluster
MACRO ENVIRONMENT
Assess global macro economic trends
STRATEGY OPPORTUNITIES
Qualitative assessment of strategy opportunity set
RISK/REWARD ANALYSIS
Estimate risk/reward for each strategy
Develop asset allocation recommendation for each
unique mandate
ASSET ALLOCATION RECOMMENDATION
StrategyClusters
Ops. Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Manager Approval Committee
Investment Committee
23Risk Management Cluster
Objective ensures risks within portfolios are
understood, intended and compensated
- Assesses the balance of risk and reward within
the portfolio in both normal and stress market
conditions - Relevant risk factors are gathered in order to
analyze fund performance and risk at both manager
and portfolio level - Qualitative and quantitative analysis increases
the robustness of the portfolio construction
process
StrategyClusters
Ops. Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Manager Approval Committee
Investment Committee
24Responsibilities of the Risk Management Cluster
QUANTITATIVE MANAGER REVIEW
Analytical decomposition of fund performance
QUANTITATIVE PORTFOLIO REVIEW
Performance-based analysis of portfolio risks,
and the relation between investments
RISK ASSESSMENT
Aggregate components of manager risk and at the
portfolio level
SCENARIO/STRESS ANALYSIS
Multifactor models to explain performance in
normal and stress environments
Continuously monitoring of actual versus targets,
benchmarks and peers
RISK LIMIT OVERSIGHT
PORTFOLIO RECOMMENDATIONS
Quantitative recommendations regarding
incremental portfolio risk of an investment
StrategyClusters
Ops. Due Diligence Cluster
Asset Allocation Cluster
Risk Management Cluster
Manager Approval Committee
Investment Committee
25Mandate discussion
- Establish expectations for return, risk and
correlation (both for normal market environments
and stress) - Client constraints are established, examples
include - strategy exposure
- types of managers
- manager concentration
- Controlling risk is much easier than controlling
return - Alternative Investment Solutions considers itself
a risk manager that manages a portfolio rather
than a portfolio manager that manages risk
26Issues surrounding transparency
There are many views on the feasibility and
importance of total transparency
- Question comes down to risk measurement versus
risk management - Hedge fund managers generally reluctant to
provide full disclosure given that other market
participants can use this information to their
advantage - particularly relevant when short positions,
controversial and illiquid securities are
involved - What level of disclosure is necessary to perform
effective and pro-active investment monitoring? - Is position level reporting as useful as costs
associated with it or the negative selection bias
it can create? - Importance of relevant risk factors,
value-at-risk analysis, stress tests, position
concentration and Greeks that are unique to
each fund strategy and sub-strategy - detail analysis without the disclosure of
sensitive information - The role of pro-active forward looking
qualitative monitoring should NOT be
underestimated
27Post 1998 environment
Aftermath since LTCM
- How has the hedge fund industry changed since
1998? - Increased appreciation of dangers of excessive
leverage and strategies that overly rely on it
for profit (i.e. certain types of fixed income
arbitrage trades) - there has been a large outflow of assets from
hedge funds that use these approaches - Limitations of value-at-risk in event of major
systemic shock (the one in a hundred year
scenario) and increased usefulness in stress
testing portfolios - importance of understanding the shifting risks to
both a single hedge fund manager and a portfolio
during normal and shock market environments - Outcome has been a general decline in leverage
across wide variety of strategies as evidenced by
lower stress losses in 9/11 - In addition, various global regulatory
authorities are beginning to dedicate more time
and resources to analyzing the hedge fund
industry and their role within the financial
markets
28Regulatory environment
Greater Oversight
- Trading areas
- Particular analysis is on relationship between
research and trading within the sell side
community and as it relates to hedge funds - Rules to restrict or increase the difficulty of
short selling would have negative effect on hedge
funds not only are shorts alpha generating (bad
companies with bad business models that are
failing) but also are exposure reducing (like
pair trading) - Non-trading areas
- In the US, the source of funds (Patriot Act
requirements) - SEC Hedge Fund Act Registration (as opposed to
Regulation) is an important underpinning for
investor confidence - Markets/countries that have placed restrictions
on hedge fund activities have seen liquidity
levels and traditional investor interest decline
sharply
29Industry maturation
Is there a hedge fund bubble?
- Recent asset inflows into hedge funds have been
strong - Nevertheless, hedge funds account for less than
6 of total market value of traditional long-only
world of all financial assets - It is important to understand not just the
absolute level of inflows but also to which
strategies the inflows are going - large inflows currently going to strategies that
need additional capital such as credit
derivatives and other evolving new markets - Hedge fund performance is cyclical and profitable
arbitrage situations ebb and flow - Certain strategies tend to be counter-cyclical to
each other (like merger arbitrage and distressed
credit), namely a diminished opportunity set in
one strategy frequently leads to improving profit
potential in the other - Hence, importance of a broad based portfolio to
capture the changing opportunity sets of various
strategies
30Expectations and tolerances
Setting these before investing is important
- Risk free interest rate alpha beta
- Libor is a good proxy for the level of interest
rates - Alpha is the ability to profit from either hedge
fund manager selection (selection effect) and
strategy allocation (allocation affect). These
typically average around 6 net a year - Beta is the intended and unintended market
movement of a portfolio. Since broad based fund
of funds portfolios function as a diversifier,
over time the beta can average around 0.20 to an
index like the SP 500
31Expectations and tolerances (contd)
Setting these before investing is important
- Given this equation, when fund of funds generated
an annual return of 14 in the late 1990s, it was
composed of an average Libor of 6, 6 in alpha
and 2 in beta (.20 beta 10 average gain in
the SP 500) - In 2002 the performance for most fund of funds
was 3, with Libor at 2, 6 in alpha and -5
beta (.20 beta -25 loss in SP) - All of this should be accomplished with an
annualized volatility between 3 to 5, a worse
monthly loss between 1 to 2 and generating
profitability 75 to 80 of all months
32Allocation Issues
- The decision to invest in hedge funds frequently
comes down to two choices invest directly or
through a fund of fund - Investing directly avoids an additional layer of
fees but introduces issues surrounding manager
selection issues (access and return dispersion)
and manager monitoring issues (disclosure and
resources) - Investing in a fund of fund product avoids this
issues but comes with an additional layer of fees - A common approach is to initially invest in a
broad based fund of fund product then, over time
and as experienced is gained, direct investments
are made to multi-strategy single hedge funds - This model is frequently referred to as
core-satellite, with the fund of funds
representing the core 75 to 80 allocation while
the satellite direct investments make up the
balance - The ultimate decision is as unique as the
individual plan sponsors business model and needs
33Conclusion
- Broad based hedge fund portfolios belong in any
investment portfolio due to the unique role they
perform when combined with traditional asset
classes - Non-correlated sources of alpha benefit any
portfolio, and should always be incorporated, no
matter what their source (hedge funds, real
estate, private equity, timber etc) - Opportunities will continue to exist
- The ability to perform regulatory arbitrage and
lock up money is a key component in capturing
alpha - Existing financial markets will inevitably grow
in tandem with real economies and new strategies
develop to exploit dislocations - Given these factors, the most logical question is
not whether to invest or not but what are the
appropriate allocation levels to make to a
traditional portfolio
34Disclaimer
Alternative Investment Solutions prepared the
information, including but not limited the charts
and graphs, contained within this presentation.
Unless otherwise noted, the information used to
create these charts and graphs was based solely
on information collected and retained in
Alternative Investment Solutions proprietary
database and is accurate as of the date so
indicated on the particular chart or graph. Third
party funds and managers contributed to the
majority of the information collected therefore,
Alternative Investment Solutions makes no
representations as to the accuracy of such source
information and the charts and graphs are subject
to change without notice to the recipient. As
such, the charts and graphs do not purport to be
a scientific or academic analysis but rather,
represent some measure of support for the
experientially based opinions of Alternative
Investment Solutions. This document does not
constitute an offer of securities. Such an offer
will only be made by means of a confidential
offering memorandum. This material is
confidential and intended solely for the
information of the person to whom it as been
delivered. Recipients may not reproduce or
transmit it, in whole or in part, to third
parties. Past performance is not indicative of
future results and future results may differ
significantly from current or historical
returns. This document has been issued through
UBS OConnor Limited for distribution to
Intermediate or Market Counterparty customers and
through UBS Global Asset Management (US) Inc. UBS
OConnor Limited (authorized and regulated by the
Financial Services Authority in the UK) and UBS
Global Asset Management (US) Inc. (a member of
NASD and SIPC) are subsidiaries of UBS AG.
35Contact information
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
- Americas
- Roy Freeman 1-203-719 5419 roy.freeman_at_ubs
.com - Dan Murphy 1-312-525 5133 daniel.murphy_at_ubs
.com
Layout Box Select this box and use it
to Insert text - type text and apply a style
Insert a Table or MS Graph Resize an object
A
A
A
A
A
A
NameTel XX-XXX-XXX XXXXemail_at_XXXX
ABC corp.
A
A
A
A
A
A
Layout Box Select this box and use it
to Insert text - type text and apply a style
Insert a Table or MS Graph Resize an object
Layout Box Select this box and use it
to Insert text - type text and apply a style
Insert a Table or MS Graph Resize an object
- UK, Europe Middle East (ex Switzerland)
- Tim Sweeting 44-20-7901
5835 tim.sweeting_at_ubs.com - Rickard Fischerstrom 44-20-7901
5819 rickard.fischerstrom_at_ubs.com
A
A
- Switzerland
- René Steiner 41-1-239 33 35 rene.steiner_at_ubs.com
- Japan/Korea
- Yukio Nagamoto 81-3-5208 7657 yukio.nagamoto_at_ubs.
com - Akiko Ueno 81-3-5208 7405 akiko.ueno_at_ubs.com
- Asia Pacific
- Howard Knight 65-6836 5465 howard.knight_at_ubs.com
- Roger Tallboys 852-2971 8225 roger.tallboys_at_u
bs.com - Theresa Han 852-2971 8832 theresa.han_at_ubs.com
- Wealth Management
- Patrick Casparis (Europe) 41-1-239 18 96
patrick.casparis_at_ubs.com - Elizabeth Sinn (Hong Kong) 852-2971 8806
elizabeth.sinn_at_ubs.com - Elaine Zhao (Singapore) 65-6836 5462
elaine.zhao_at_ubs.com - Shelia Plaisance (Americas) 1-203-719
1506 shelia.plaisance_at_ubs.com
- Enhanced Index
- Tiziana Holmgren 1-203-719 6223
tiziana.holmgren_at_ubs.com
Registered representatives of UBS Global Asset
Management (US) Inc.