Title: UNDERSTANDING THE CODEX ALIMENTARIUS
1UNDERSTANDING THE CODEX ALIMENTARIUS
2- The Codex Alimentarius, or the food code, has
become the seminal global reference point for
consumers, food producers and processors,
national food control agencies and the
international food trade. The code has had an
enormous impact on the thinking of food producers
and processors as well as on the awareness of the
end users - the consumers. Its influence extends
to every continent, and its contribution to the
protection of public health and fair practices in
the food trade is immeasurable.
3- The Codex Alimentarius system presents a unique
opportunity for all countries to join the
international community in formulating and
harmonizing food standards and ensuring their
global implementation. It also allows them a
role in the development of codes governing
hygienic processing practices and recommendations
relating to compliance with those standards.
4- The significance of the food code for consumer
health protection was underscored in 1985 by the
United Nations Resolution 39/248, whereby
guidelines were adopted for use in the
elaboration and reinforcement of consumer
protection policies. The guidelines advise that
"Governments should take into account the need of
all consumers for food security and should
support and, as far as possible, adopt standards
from the ... Codex Alimentarius" of FAO and the
World Health Organization.
5- The Codex Alimentarius has relevance to the
international food trade. With respect to the
ever-increasing global market, in particular, the
advantages of having universally uniform food
standards for the protection of consumers are
self-evident. It is not surprising, therefore,
that the Agreement on the Application of Sanitary
and Phytosanitary Measures (SPS) and the
Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT)
both encourage the international harmonization of
food standards
6- A product of the Uruguay Round of multinational
trade negotiations, the SPS Agreement cites Codex
standards, guidelines and recommendations as the
preferred international measures for facilitating
international trade in food. As such, Codex
standards have become the benchmarks against
which national food measures and regulations are
evaluated within the legal parameters of the
Uruguay Round Agreements.
7The Codex achievement
- A SINGLE INTERNATIONAL REFERENCE POINT
- GREATER GLOBAL AND NATIONAL AWARENESS
- INCREASED CONSUMER PROTECTION
- BROAD COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT
- A CODE OF SCIENTIFICALLY SOUND STANDARDS
8A SINGLE INTERNATIONAL REFERENCE POINT
- In the best traditions of the Food and
Agriculture Organization (FAO) and the World
Health Organization (WHO), as part of its
persistent endeavours to develop the Codex
Alimentarius the Commission has encouraged
food-related scientific and technological
research as well as discussion. In doing so, it
has lifted the world community's awareness of
food safety and related issues to unprecedented
heights and has consequently become the single
most important international reference point for
developments associated with food standards.
9GREATER GLOBAL AND NATIONAL AWARENESS
- It is now common for consumers to demand that
their governments take legislative action to
ensure that only safe food of acceptable quality
is sold and that the risk of food-borne health
hazards is minimized - In fact, governments are extremely conscious of
the political consequences to be expected should
they fail to heed consumers' concerns regarding
the food they eat.
10INCREASED CONSUMER PROTECTION
- The Codex Alimentarius Commission has been
supported in its work by the now universally
accepted maxim that people have the right to
expect their food to be safe, of good quality and
suitable for consumption. - Poor-quality food can destroy the commercial
credibility of suppliers, both nationally and
internationally, while food spoilage is wasteful
and costly and can adversely affect trade and
consumer confidence.
11BROAD COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT
- The task of creating a food code is immense and,
because of continuing research and product
development, virtually endless. The finalization
of food standards and their compilation into a
code that is credible and authoritative requires
extensive consultation as well as the collection
and evaluation of information, followed up by
confirmation of final results and sometimes
objective compromise to satisfy differing sound,
scientifically based views
12- Creating standards that at once protect
consumers, ensure fair practices in the sale of
food and facilitate trade is a process that
involves specialists in numerous food-related
scientific disciplines, together with consumers'
organizations, production and processing
industries, food control administrators and
traders.
13A CODE OF SCIENTIFICALLY SOUND STANDARDS
- In support of its work on food standards and
codes of practice, it generates reputable
scientific texts, convenes numerous expert
committees and consultations as well as
international meetings attended by the
best-informed individuals and organizations
concerned with food and related fields. Countries
have responded by introducing long-overdue food
legislation and Codex-based standards and by
establishing or strengthening food control
agencies to monitor compliance with such
regulations.
14Origins of the Codex Alimentarius
- ANCIENT TIMES
- A SCIENTIFIC BASE
- INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENTS
- TRADE CONCERNS
- CONSUMERS' CONCERNS
- A DESIRE FOR LEADERSHIP
- INTEGRATING NON-GOVERNMENTAL ACTIVITIES
- INTERNATIONAL CONSULTATION AND COOPERATION
15ANCIENT TIMES
- Evidence from the earliest historical writings
indicates that governing authorities were already
then concerned with codifying rules to protect
consumers from dishonest practices in the sale of
food. Assyrian tablets described the method to be
used in determining the correct weights and
measures for foodgrains, and Egyptian scrolls
prescribed the labelling to be applied to certain
foods. In ancient Athens, beer and wines were
inspected for purity and soundness, and the
Romans had a well-organized state food control
system to protect consumers from fraud or bad
produce.
16- In Europe during the Middle Ages, individual
countries passed laws concerning the quality and
safety of eggs, sausages, cheese, beer, wine and
bread. Some of these ancient statutes still exist
today.
17A SCIENTIFIC BASE
- The second half of the nineteenth century saw the
first general food laws adopted and basic food
control systems put in place to monitor
compliance. - During the same period, food chemistry came to
be recognized as a reputable discipline and the
determination of the "purity" of a food was
primarily based on the chemical parameters of
simple food composition.
18- When harmful industrial chemicals were used to
disguise the true colour or nature of food, the
concept of "adulteration" was extended to include
the use of hazardous chemicals in food. - Science had begun providing tools with which to
disclose dishonest practices in the sale of food
and to distinguish between safe and unsafe edible
products.
19INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENTS
- In the Austro-Hungarian Empire between 1897 and
1911, a collection of standards and product
descriptions for a wide variety of foods was
developed as the Codex Alimentarius Austriacus. - Although lacking legal force, it was used as a
reference by the courts to determine standards of
identity for specific foods. The present-day
Codex Alimentarius draws its name from the
Austrian code.
20TRADE CONCERNS
- The different sets of standards arising from the
spontaneous and independent development of food
laws and standards by different countries
inevitably gave rise to trade barriers that were
of increasing concern to food traders in the
early twentieth century.
21- Trade associations that were formed as a
reaction to such barriers pressured governments
to harmonize their various food standards so as
to facilitate trade in safe foods of a defined
quality
22- The International Dairy Federation (IDF),
founded in 1903, was one such association. Its
work on standards for milk and milk products
later provided a catalyst in the establishment of
the Codex Alimentarius Commission and in the
setting of its procedures for elaborating
standards.
23- When FAO and WHO were founded in the late 1940s,
there was heightened international concern about
the direction being taken in the field of food
regulation.
24CONSUMERS' CONCERNS
- In the 1940s, rapid progress was made in food
science and technology. With the advent of more
sensitive analytical tools, knowledge about the
nature of food, its quality and associated health
hazards also grew quickly. There was intense
interest in food microbiology, food chemistry and
associated disciplines, and new discoveries were
considered newsworthy.
25- Despite the questionable quality of some of the
information disseminated, however, the outcome
was an increase in the public's food
consciousness and, consequently, knowledge about
food safety gradually grew.
26- At the same time, as more and more information
about food and related matters became available,
there was greater apprehension on the part of
consumers. Whereas, previously, consumers'
concerns had extended only as far as the
"visibles"- underweight contents, size
variations, misleading labelling and poor quality
- they now embraced a fear of the "invisibles",
i.e. health hazards could not be seen, smelled
or tasted, such as micro-organisms, pesticide
residues, environmental contaminants and food
additives.
27A DESIRE FOR LEADERSHIP
- Food regulators, traders, consumers and experts
were looking increasingly to FAO and WHO for
leadership in unravelling the skein of food
regulations that were impeding trade and
providing mostly inadequate protection for
consumers.
28- In 1953, WHO's governing body, the World Health
Assembly, stated that the widening use of
chemicals in food presented a new public health
problem, and it was proposed that the two
organizations should conduct relevant studies.
One such study identified the use of food
additives as a critical factor.
29- As a result, FAO and WHO convened the first joint
FAO/WHO Conference on Food Additives in 1955.
From that Conference eventuated the Joint FAO/WHO
Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA) which,
more than 40 years after its inception, still
meets regularly
30INTEGRATING NON-GOVERNMENTAL ACTIVITIES
- While FAO and WHO furthered their involvement in
food-related matters, a variety of committees set
up by international non-governmental
organizations (NGOs) also began working in
earnest on standards for food commodities.
31INTERNATIONAL CONSULTATION AND COOPERATION
- Two landmark years in the foundation of the Codex
Alimentarius were 1960 and 1961
32- In October 1960, the first FAO Regional
Conference for Europe crystallized a widely held
view when it recognized - "The desirability of international agreement on
minimum food standards and related questions
(including labelling requirements, methods of
analysis, etc.) ... as an important means of
protecting the consumer's health, of ensuring
quality and of reducing trade barriers,
particularly in the rapidly integrating market of
Europe."
33- In November 1961, the Eleventh Session of the
Conference of FAO passed a resolution to set up
the Codex Alimentarius Commission. - In May 1963, the Sixteenth World Health Assembly
approved the establishment of the Joint FAO/WHO
Food Standards Programme and adopted the statutes
of the Codex Alimentarius Commission.
34- The Codex system FAO, WHO and the Codex
Alimentarius Commission
35THE COMMISSION
- The Statutes
- The Rules of Procedure
- Representation.
36THE COMMISSION'S OPERATIONS
- Compiling the Codex Alimentarius
- The legal base for the Commission's operations
and the procedures it is required to follow are
published in the Codex Alimentarius - procedural
manual,
37- submission of a proposal
- decision by the Commission or the Executive
Committee that a standard be developed - a proposed draft standard
- circulated to Member Governments for comment.
- a draft standard
- a Codex standard
38- Once adopted by the Commission, a Codex standard
is added to the Codex Alimentarius.
39- A "Format for Codex Commodity Standards and their
Content" is provided by the General Principles of
the Codex Alimentarius. It includes the following
categories of information - Scope - including the name of the standard
- Description, essential composition and quality
factors - defining the minimum standard for the
food - Food additives - only those cleared by FAO and
WHO may be used - Contaminants
- Hygiene and weights and measures
- Labelling - in accordance with the Codex General
Standard for the Labelling of Prepackaged Foods - Methods of analysis and sampling.
40- In addition to commodity standards, the Codex
Alimentarius includes general standards, which
have across-the-board application to all foods
and are not product-specific. There are general
standards or recommendations for - food labelling
- food additives
- contaminants
- methods of analysis and sampling
- food hygiene
- nutrition and foods for special dietary uses
- food import and export inspection and
certification systems - residues of veterinary drugs in foods
- pesticide residues in foods.
41- Revision of Codex standards. The Commission and
its subsidiary bodies are committed to revision
of Codex standards and related texts as necessary
to ensure they are consistent with and reflect
current scientific knowledge
42Structure of the Codex Alimentarius
- Volume 1A - General requirements
- Volume 1B - General requirements (food hygiene)
- Volume 2A - Pesticide residues in foods (general
texts) - Volume 2B - Pesticide residues in foods (maximum
residue limits) - Volume 3 - Residues of veterinary drugs in foods
- Volume 4 - Foods for special dietary uses
(including foods for infants and children) - Volume 5A - Processed and quick-frozen fruits and
vegetables - Volume 5B - Fresh fruits and vegetables
- Volume 6 - Fruit juices
- Volume 7 - Cereals, pulses (legumes) and derived
products and vegetable proteins - Volume 8 - Fats and oils and related products
- Volume 9 - Fish and fishery products
- Volume 10 - Meat and meat products soups and
broths - Volume 11 - Sugars, cocoa products and chocolate
and miscellaneous products - Volume 12 - Milk and milk products
- Volume 13 - Methods of analysis and sampling
43- Collectively, the volumes contain general
principles, general standards, definitions,
codes, commodity standards, methods and
recommendations. The contents list of each volume
is well organized for ease of reference. For
example
44- Volume 1A - General Requirements
- 1. General Principles of the Codex
Alimentarius2. Definitions for the Purpose of
Codex Alimentarius3. Code of Ethics for
International Trade in Foods4. Food Labelling5.
Food Additives - including the General Standard
for Food Additives6. Contaminants in Food -
including the General Standard for Contaminants
and Toxins in Foods7. Irradiated Foods8. Food
Import and Export Food Inspection and
Certification Systems
45SUBSIDIARY BODIES
- two kinds of subsidiary body
- Codex Committees, which prepare draft standards
for submission to the Commission. - Coordinating Committees, through which regions or
groups of countries coordinate food standards
activities in the region, including the
development of regional standards.
46General Subject Committees
- Committee on General Principles, hosted by France
- Committee on Food Labelling, hosted by Canada
- Committee on Methods of Analysis and Sampling,
hosted by Hungary - Committee on Food Hygiene, hosted by the United
States - Committee on Pesticide Residues, hosted by the
Netherlands - Committee on Food Additives and Contaminants,
hosted by the Netherlands - Committee on Import/Export Inspection and
Certification Systems, hosted by Australia - Committee on Nutrition and Foods for Special
Dietary Uses, hosted by Germany (a General
Committee for the purpose of Nutrition) - Committee on Residues of Veterinary Drugs in
Food, hosted by the United States
47Commodity Committees
- Committee on Fats and Oils, hosted by the United
Kingdom - Committee on Fish and Fishery Products, hosted by
Norway - Committee on Milk and Milk Products (formerly the
FAO/WHO Committee of Government Experts on the
Code of Principles for Milk and Milk Products),
hosted by New Zealand - Committee on Fresh Fruits and Vegetables, hosted
by Mexico - Committee on Cocoa Products and Chocolate, hosted
by Switzerland - Committee on Sugars, hosted by the United Kingdom
- Committee on Processed Fruits and Vegetables,
hosted by the United States - Committee on Vegetable Proteins, hosted by Canada
- Committee on Cereals, Pulses and Legumes, hosted
by the United States - Committee on Processed Meat and Poultry Products,
hosted by Denmark - Committee on Soups and Broths, hosted by
Switzerland - Committee on Meat Hygiene, hosted by New Zealand
- Committee on Natural Mineral Waters, hosted by
Switzerland
48Coordinating Committees
- Africa
- Asia
- Europe
- Latin America and the Caribbean
- North America and Southwest Pacific
49- MEMBER COUNTRIES' ACCEPTANCE OF CODEX STANDARDS
- The harmonization of food standards is generally
viewed as a prerequisite to the protection of
consumer health as well as allowing the fullest
possible facilitation of international trade. For
that reason, the Uruguay Round Agreements on the
Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary
Measures (SPS) and Technical Barriers to Trade
(TBT) both encourage the international
harmonization of food standards.
50- Harmonization can only be achieved when all
countries adopt the same standards
51- The General Principles of the Codex Alimentarius
specify the ways in which member countries may
"accept" Codex standards. Forms of acceptance
vary somewhat depending on whether the standard
is a commodity standard, a general standard, or
concerns levels for pesticide or veterinary drug
residues or food additives. Generally, however,
the proposed forms of acceptance are full
acceptance, acceptance with minor deviations and
free distribution.
52FAO, WHO AND THE CODEX RELATIONSHIP
- FAO and WHO complement the Commission's
activities significantly in a number of practical
ways. To adopt Codex standards, countries require
an adequate food law as well as a technical and
administrative infrastructure with the capacity
to implement it and ensure compliance. For many
years, FAO and WHO have been providing assistance
to developing countries to enable them to take
full advantage of the Commission's work
53Codex and consumers
- COMMITMENT IN THE INTEREST OF CONSUMERS
- WHAT CODEX HAS PRODUCED TO PROTECT CONSUMERS
54COMMITMENT IN THE INTEREST OF CONSUMERS
- From their beginnings, FAO and WHO have assisted
in the improvement of quality and safety
standards applied to food. The highest priority
of the Codex Alimentarius Commission, as stated
in Article 1 of its statutes, is to protect the
health of consumers and ensure fair practices in
the food trade.
55WHAT CODEX HAS PRODUCED TO PROTECT CONSUMERS
- Food commodity and general standards
- General principles, guidelines and recommended
codes of practice - Consumers' participation in the work of the
Commission and its subsidiary committees - Information
- Strengthened food control systems
56- The General Principles of Food Hygiene are
supported by detailed codes of hygienic practice
that have specific application to
57- low-acid and acidified low-acid canned foods
- aseptically processed and packaged low-acid
foods - precooked and cooked foods in mass catering
- the preparation and sale of street-vended foods
(regional standard - Latin America and the
Caribbean) - spices and dried plants
- canned fruit and vegetable products
- dried fruits
- desiccated coconut
- dehydrated fruits and vegetables including edible
fungi
58- tree nuts
- groundnuts (peanuts)
- processed meat and poultry products
- poultry processing
- egg products
- the processing of frog legs
- fresh meat
- the production, storage and composition of
mechanically separated meat and poultry meat
intended for further processing - game
- the collection, processing and marketing of
natural mineral waters.
59- The Codex Alimentarius also contains the
Recommended International Code of Practice for
Control of the Use of Veterinary Drugs, which has
the express aim of preventing the use of drugs
that create a hazard to human health.
60Codex and the international food trade
- THE URUGUAY ROUND AND WORLD FOOD TRADE
- CODEX AND THE ETHICS OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE
61THE URUGUAY ROUND AND WORLD FOOD TRADE
- The Uruguay Round Agreements represent a
milestone in the multilateral trading system
because, for the first time, they incorporated
agriculture and food under operationally
effective rules and disciplines.
62- Country participants in the round of negotiations
recognized that measures ostensibly adopted by
national governments to protect the health of
their consumers, animals and plants could become
disguised barriers to trade as well as being
discriminatory. Consequently, the SPS and the TBT
Agreements were included among the Multilateral
Agreements on Trade in Goods, annexed to the 1994
Marrakesh Agreement which established the Word
Trade Organization (WTO).
63- The Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and
Phytosanitary Measures acknowledges that
governments have the right to take sanitary and
phytosanitary measures necessary for the
protection of human health. However, the SPS
Agreement requires them to apply those measures
only to the extent required to protect human
health. It does not permit Member Governments to
discriminate by applying different requirements
to different countries where the same or similar
conditions prevail, unless there is sufficient
scientific justification for doing so.
64- The Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade
seeks to ensure that technical regulations and
standards, including packaging, marking and
labelling requirements, and analytical procedures
for assessing conformity with technical
regulations and standards do not create
unnecessary obstacles to trade.
65- It is noteworthy that the SPS and TBT Agreements
both acknowledge the importance of harmonizing
standards internationally so as to minimize or
eliminate the risk of sanitary, phytosanitary and
other technical standards becoming barriers to
trade.
66- In its pursuance of harmonization, with regard to
food safety the SPS Agreement has identified and
chosen the standards, guidelines and
recommendations established by the Codex
Alimentarius Commission for food additives,
veterinary drug and pesticide residues,
contaminants, methods of analysis and sampling,
and codes and guidelines of hygienic practice
67- This means that Codex standards are considered
scientifically justified and are accepted as the
benchmarks against which national measures and
regulations are evaluated.
68- Considerable interest in the Commission's
activities has been stimulated by the specific
recognition of Codex standards, guidelines and
recommendations within the SPS Agreement as well
as the importance assumed by Codex standards in
the Technical Regulations and Standards
provisions contained in Article 2 of the TBT
Agreement.
69- Consequently, attendance at Codex meetings,
especially by developing countries, has markedly
increased
70- The adoption of Codex standards as scientifically
justified norms for the purpose of the SPS and
TBT Agreements is of immense significance
71- The standards have become an integral part of the
legal framework within which international trade
is being facilitated through harmonization.
72CODEX AND THE ETHICS OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE
- The work of the Codex Alimentarius Commission
goes beyond creating means of removing barriers
to trade. It also includes encouraging food
traders to adopt voluntarily ethical practices as
an important way of protecting consumers' health
and promoting fair practices in the food trade.
To this end, the Commission has published the
Code of Ethics for International Trade in Food,
which is included in the Codex Alimentarius.
73- A principal objective of the Code of Ethics is to
stop exporting countries and exporters from
dumping poor-quality or unsafe food on to
international markets. The code is currently
being updated to reflect the impact of the SPS,
the TBT and other agreements on international
trade.
74- CODEX AND REGIONAL TRADE AGREEMENTS AND
ARRANGEMENTS
75- The Uruguay Round Agreements provide for groups
of member countries to enter into trade
agreements among themselves for the purpose of
liberalizing trade. The North American Free Trade
Agreement (NAFTA) between Canada, the United
States and Mexico is such an agreement.
Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay have
signed the Treaty of Acunción establishing the
Southern Common Market (MERCOSUR). In Asia and
the Pacific, 18 countries have formalized
economic cooperation arrangements under the
title, Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC)
Council.
76- NAFTA includes two ancillary agreements dealing
with sanitary and phytosanitary measures and
technical barriers to trade. With regard to SPS
measures, Codex standards are cited as basic
requirements to be met by the three member
countries in terms of the health and safety
aspects of food products.
77- MERCOSUR's Food Commission has recommended a
range of Codex standards for adoption by member
countries and is using other Codex standards as
points of reference in continuing deliberations.
78- APEC has drafted a Mutual Recognition Arrangement
on Conformity Assessment of Foods and Food
Products. This calls for consistency with SPS and
TBT requirements as well as with Codex standards,
including the recommendations of the Codex
Committee on Food Import and Export Certification
Systems.
79- In addition, EU directives frequently refer to
the Codex Alimentarius as the basis for their
requirements.
80Codex and science
- From the very beginning, the Codex Alimentarius
has been a science-based activity. - It is fair to say that the work of the Codex
Alimentarius Commission, together with that of
FAO and WHO in their supportive roles, has
provided a focal point for food-related
scientific research and investigation, and the
Commission itself has become an important
international medium for the exchange of
scientific information about food
81- The membership of expert consultations is of
critical importance. The credibility and
acceptability of any conclusions and
recommendations depend to a very large degree on
the objectiveness, scientific skill and overall
competence of the members who formulate them.
82- A large amount of scientifically based food data
has been generated by expert meetings, convened
and serviced jointly by FAO and WHO.
83- Two such groups, the Joint FAO/WHO Meeting on
Pesticide Residues and the Joint FAO/WHO Expert
Committee on Food Additives, have for many years
produced internationally acclaimed data which are
widely used by governments, industry and research
centres
84Codex administration
- The Secretary of the Codex Alimentarius
Commission is a senior FAO official who serves as
the Chief of the Joint FAO/WHO Food Standards
Programmes, located within the Food Quality and
Standards Service of the Food and Nutrition
Division at FAO in Rome.
85Codex and the future
- Codex activities of the future will differ
considerably from what they have been until now. - Scientific developments in fields relating to
food, changing attitudes of consumers, new
approaches to food control, changing perceptions
of government and food industry responsibilities
and changing food quality and safety concepts
will present the Commission with new challenges
and, conceivably, the need for new standards.
86- The application of biotechnology to food
processing and production of raw food materials
is already under scrutiny by the Commission,
which is continually examining new concepts and
systems associated with food safety and the
protection of consumers against health hazards.