Title: Ulcerative Colitis And Dysplasia Management
1Ulcerative Colitis And DysplasiaManagement
- César Yaghi, MD
- Service de Gastro-entérologie
- Hotel Dieu de France
- Université Saint Joseph
2Plan
- Introduction
- Incidence of colorectal cancer and dysplasia in
IBD - Risk factors for CRC
- Preventive treatments
- Screening for dysplasia and CRC
- Management of abnormal screening findings
- Conclusion
3INTRODUCTION
- Strategies for detecting colon cancer and/or
dysplasia in patients with inflammatory bowel
disease. - REVIEWERS' CONCLUSIONS
- No clear evidence that surveillance colonoscopy
prolongs survival in patients with extensive
colitis. - There is evidence that cancers tend to be
detected at an earlier stage in patients who are
undergoing surveillance and these patients have a
correspondingly better prognosis but lead-time
bias could contribute substantially to this
apparent benefit. - There is indirect evidence that surveillance is
likely to be effective at reducing the risk of
death from IBD-associated colorectal cancer - Indirect evidence that it is acceptably
cost-effective.
Mpofu C Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
2004(2)CD000279
4Plan
- Introduction
- Incidence of colorectal cancer and dysplasia in
IBD - Risk factors for CRC
- Preventive medical treatments
- Screening for dysplasia and CRC
- Management of abnormal screening findings
- Conclusion
5Incidence of Colorectal Cancer in Inflammatory
Bowel Disease
- Ulcerative colitis CRC Prevalence 3.7.
- The risk increased with duration of disease
- 2 incidence of cancer after 10 years
- 8 incidence after 20 years
- 18 incidence after 30 years of disease.
- 1/3 deaths related to ulcerative colitis.
- Eaden Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2004 20
424-30 - Similar risk for colorectal cancer in Crohn
disease and in ulcerative colitis. - 20-year cumulative incidences of CRC identical in
extensive Crohn disease of the colon and equally
extensive ulcerative colitis. - Gillen Gut. 1994 351590-2
- In Crohn colitis, the relative risk 5.6,
similar to ulcerative colitis. - Ekbom Lancet. 1990 11336357-9
6Ekbom, et al NEJM, 1990
7PSC and Colon Cancer Risk
8Plan
- Introduction
- Incidence of colorectal cancer and dysplasia in
IBD - Risk factors for CRC
- Preventive treatments
- Screening for dysplasia and CRC
- Management of abnormal screening findings
- Conclusion
9Risk Factors for Colon Cancer in Ulcerative
Colitis and Crohns colitis
Importance
Risk Factor
Choi PM, et al. Gastroenterol Clin North Am
199524671-87. Eaden J. Am J Gastroenterol
2000952710-2719.
10Severity of inflammation is a risk factor for
colorectal neoplasia in ulcerative colitis
- the histological inflammation score (odds ratio,
4.7 P lt 0.001).
Rutter et al Gastroenterology. 2004 126451
11Plan
- Introduction
- Incidence of colorectal cancer and dysplasia in
IBD - Risk factors for CRC
- Preventive treatments
- Screening for dysplasia and CRC
- Management of abnormal screening findings
- Conclusion
12Prevention of Colon Cancer in UC/CD
- Chemoprevention
- 5-ASA 1.2 gm once daily (Eaden, APT, 1999)
- Folic acid 1 mg daily (Lashner, Gastro, 1997)
- Ursodiol 300 mg bid (PSC) (Tung, Ann Int Med,
2001) - Insufficient evidence to modify screening and
surveillance in UC patients who use these
medications. - Surgery (ileo-anal anastomosis)
- DALM, high grade dysplasia, ? low grade dysplasia
135-aminosalicylate use and colorectal cancer risk
in inflammatory bowel disease
- 18,969 patients, of whom 100 patients had
developed CRC during 5-ASA exposure. (76 patients
had a history of ulcerative colitis ) .
Van Staa TP Gut. 2005 Jun 30 Epub ahead of print
14Effect of 5-aminosalicylate use on colorectal
cancer and dysplasia risk
- Nine studies (3 cohort, 6 case-control)
- 1,932 subjects satisfied all inclusion criteria.
- 334 cases of CRC,
- 140 cases of dysplasia,
- Protective association between 5-aminosalicylates
and CRC or a combined endpoint of CRC/dysplasia
in patients with ulcerative colitis. Additional
studies analyzing the effect of 5-ASA on risk of
dysplasia are needed.
Velayos et al. Am J Gastroenterol. 2005
1001345-53.
15Surgical Prophylaxis
- It has been recommended by some experts to
consider total proctocolectomy for patients with
greater than 8 to 10 years of extensive disease. - Total proctocolectomy is not without many
potential complications, including pouch failure,
increasing stool frequency, incontinence, and
pouchitis. - Patients with ileoanal pouch anastomosis still
maintain a small potential risk for the
development of colorectal cancer in the rectal
cuff itself.
16Plan
- Introduction
- Incidence of colorectal cancer and dysplasia in
IBD - Risk factors for CRC
- Preventive treatments
- Screening for dysplasia and CRC
- Management of abnormal screening findings
- Conclusion
17Consensus Conference Colorectal Cancer Screening
and Surveillance in Inflammatory Bowel
DiseaseSteven H. Itzkowitz, and Daniel H.
Presentfor the Crohns and Colitis Foundation
ofAmerica Colon Cancer in IBD Study
GroupInflamm Bowel Dis Volume 11, Number 3,
March 2005
18Colorectal Cancer Screening and Surveillance in
Inflammatory Bowel Disease
- Duration of Disease
- screening colonoscopy 8 to 10 years after the
onset of symptoms attributable to UC. - The purpose
- reestablish disease extent
- look for evidence of dysplasia.
- Regular surveillance colonoscopy after a
screening examination. - Anatomic Extent
- Patients with UC classified into 1 of 3
categories - Extensive if there is evidence of UC proximal to
the splenic flexure, - Left-sided if UC is present in the descending
colon up to, but not proximal to, the splenic
flexure, - Proctosigmoiditis if disease is limited to the
rectum with or without sigmoid colon involvement - The extent of involvement defined either at
diagnosis or screening, whichever reveals more
extensive involvement. - Colonoscopy preferred to flexible sigmoidoscopy.
19Gross versus microscopic pancolitis and the
occurrence of neoplasia in ulcerative colitis.
- Thirty-six patients with colitis-related
dysplasia/CRC were identified from colectomy
specimen of whom 30 had slides available for
review. - Gross pancolitis was identified in 19 patients,
though microscopic pancolitis was evident in all
30 patients. Among the 11 patients with only
distal gross colitis, 4/15 neoplastic lesions
were proximal to the area of gross involvement. - UC-related neoplasia can occur in areas of the
colon not grossly involved with colitis, though
it did not occur in any patients without
microscopic pancolitis.
Mathy C Inflamm Bowel Dis. 2003 Nov9(6)351-5.
20Colorectal Cancer Screening and Surveillance in
Inflammatory Bowel Disease
- Primary Sclerosing Cholangitis
- not previously known to have IBD colonoscopy to
determine the status. - Biopsies from normal-appearing mucosa, for
microscopic evidence of colitis - If IBD demonstrated screening and subsequent
surveillance since PSC onset. - Age of Onset
- insufficient evidence to support starting
screening and surveillance before 8 years of
disease - screening and surveillance based on other risk
factors.
21Colorectal Cancer Screening and Surveillance in
Inflammatory Bowel Disease
- Positive Family History of CRC
- A positive family history of CRC is a risk factor
for CRC in UC patients. - Insufficient evidence to warrant altering either
the initiation of surveillance or the interval
between examinations based on this information. - Obtain a detailed family history for intestinal
and extraintestinal neoplasia and incorporate any
evidence of heightened risk into the clinical
decision making. - Degree of Endoscopic and Histologic Activity
- Increased severity of inflammation, both
endoscopically and histologically, Correlates
with increased frequency of dysplasia. - patients with longstanding quiescent colitis
remain at risk for developing CRC.
22Timing of Screening Exams
- A screening colonoscopy should be performed in UC
- rule out colonic neoplasia (dysplasia or cancer)
8 to 10 years after the onset of UC symptoms. - Extent of disease should also be evaluated, with
possible reclassification of extent if there is
significant change.
23Timing of Surveillance Exams
- Patients with extensive colitis or left-sided
colitis who have a negative screening colonoscopy
should begin surveillance within 1 to 2 years. - negative surveillance colonoscopy subsequent
surveillance examinations should be performed
every 1 to 2 years. - With 2 negative examinations, the next
surveillance examination may be performed in 1 to
3 years until 20 years. - gt20 years performing surveillance every 1 to 2
years - Patients with PSC surveillance yearly.
- Patients with other risk factors, such as
positive family history of CRC, may require
shorter surveillance intervals. - Proctosigmoiditis should be managed according
to standard CRC prevention
24Dysplasia arising in chronic ulcerative
colitisThe presence of nodular masses arising in
a mucosa affected by ulcerative colitis are
suspicious for malignancy.
25Colonoscopic Practice
- a minimum of 33 biopsies
- 4-quadrant biopsies every 10 cm
- Particularly in UC, consideration should be given
to taking 4-quadrant biopsies every 5 cm in the
lower sigmoid and rectum, because the frequency
of CRC is higher in this region.
26The detection of colitis-associated colorectal
cancer during colonoscopy
- difficult because the dysplasia may be present in
macroscopically normal mucosa - only 20 to 50 of intraepithelial neoplasias can
be detected by routine colonoscopy. - Cancers in ulcerative colitis grow in a diffusely
infiltrating pattern, also hindering the
macroscopic diagnosis of dysplasia.
27Dysplasia associated lesion/mass.
Rutter, M D et al. Gut 200453256-260
28Dysplastic lesion highlighted by indigo carmine
dye spray.
Rutter, M D et al. Gut 200453256-260
29Role of chromoendoscopy for the detection of
intraepithelial neoplasia and colon cancer in
ulcerative colitis.
- The targeted biopsy protocol detects dysplasia in
significantly more patients than the non-targeted
protocol - targeted biopsy protocol with pancolonic
chromoendoscopy requires fewer biopsies - better evaluation of degree and extent of colonic
inflammation - Using the modified pit pattern classification,
both the sensitivity and specificity for
differentiation between non-neoplastic and
neoplastic lesions were 93.
Matsumoto T Am J Gastroenterol. 2003
Aug98(8)1827-33 Gut. 2004 Feb53(2)256-60 Kiess
lich R Gastroenterology. 2003 Apr124(4)880-8.
30Figure 1 Pit pattern classification according to
Kudo and colleagues.16. The typical crypt
architecture of types I-V are indicated (A). (B)
Examples of type I (left) and type IV (right)
lesions before and after chromoendoscopy.
Kiesslich, R et al. Gut 200453165-167
31Seven guidelines for chromoendoscopy in
ulcerative colitis
32Seven guidelines for chromoendoscopy in
ulcerative colitis
33Plan
- Introduction
- Incidence of colorectal cancer and dysplasia in
IBD - Risk factors for CRC
- Preventive treatments
- Screening for dysplasia and CRC
- Management of abnormal screening findings
- Conclusion
34Progression of flat low-grade dysplasia to
advanced neoplasia in patients with ulcerative
colitis
- The rate of neoplastic progression was 33 - 53
at 5 years.
Ullman Am J Gastroenterol. 2002 Apr97(4)922-7
Ullman T Gastroenterology. 2003 Nov125(5)1311-9
35Management of Abnormal FindingsDefinition of
abnormal findings
- Any examination in which a single biopsy reveals
mucosal changes interpreted as indefinite for
dysplasia, low-grade dysplasia (LGD),
high-grade dysplasia (HGD), or
adenocarcinoma - Biopsies
- Patients who have lt 33 biopsies / colonoscopy are
more likely to have a missed diagnosis of
neoplasia - Should be confirmed by an experienced
gastrointestinal pathologist. - The decision for recommending colectomy should be
considered in light of - the quality of the preparation
- sufficient biopsies taken
- the presence of active inflammation that can
occasionally make interpretation of the biopsies
difficult.
36Recommended management strategies for abnormal
findings
- Indefinite for Dysplasia in Flat Mucosa
- If the diagnosis is confirmed, a follow-up
surveillance examination should be performed
within 3 to 6 months. - LGD in Flat Mucosa
- Progression from LGD to HGD or CRC 50-55
- Unrecognized synchronous CRC 20
- Unifocal or Multifocal flat LGD prophylactic
total proctocolectomy. - If operative strategy deferred or the patient
elects to continue with surveillance, repeat
examination within 3-6 months - Repeat exams
- extensive biopsy protocol
- patients who elect to pursue a nonoperative
strategy for LGD continued, more frequent exams
(6 mo) is recommended to ensure that the
diagnosis is correct. - HGD in Flat Mucosa
- If confirmed, total proctocolectomy
37Raised Lesions (Polyps) with Dysplasia
- Polypectomy and biopsies of surrounding mucosa (4
biopsies adjacent to the raised lesion and
submitted separately) - Negative for dysplasia, and no dysplasia
elsewhere in the colon, follow-up examination
should be performed within 6 months, with regular
surveillance resumed if no dysplasia is found. - Dysplasia present in the surrounding mucosa, or
polypoid lesion nonresectable or does not
resemble a typical adenoma (DALM), a high risk of
associated synchronous CRC would justify
recommending a complete proctocolectomy. - Adenoma-like polyps in areas of the colon
endoscopically and microscopically free of
disease - to be managed according to standard
recommendations for postpolypectomy follow-up of
sporadic adenomas
38Conclusion
- Screening recommendations
- Frequency
- Timing
- Identifying dysplasia
- Number of biopsies
- Chromoendoscopy
- Trained pathologist
- Appropriate management
- Surgical treatment
- Surveillance