Title: BDO SEIDMAN, LLPS October 2006 FINANCIAL REPORTING UPDATE
1BDO SEIDMAN, LLPSOctober 2006FINANCIAL
REPORTING UPDATE
2Speakers and Replay Information
- Speakers
- Jeff Lenz
- Ben Neuhausen
- Replay Access
- www.bdo.com/about/publications/assurance
3Agenda
- SEC Update
- GAAP Update
- Questions and Answers
4 SEC UPDATEOctober 2006
5SEC Update Agenda
- Rulemaking
- Personnel Changes
- SAB 108 Effects of Prior Year Errors
- Stock Option Accounting
- Other SEC Practice Issues
6Recent Rulemaking
- Executive Compensation and Related Person
Disclosure (Release 33-8732A) - http//www.sec.gov/rules/final/2006/33-8732a.pdf
- Transition Questions and Answers
(http//www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/faqs/execcom
pqa.pdf) - Request for Additional Comment Release 33-8735
(http//www.sec.gov/rules/proposed/2006/33-8735.pd
f) - Amendments to the Tender Offer Best-Price Rule
(http//www.sec.gov/news/press/2006/2006-177.htm)
7404 ImplementationNext Steps SEC
- Defer compliance dates
- Completed Release 33-8730A (http//www.sec.gov/r
ules/final/2006/33-8730a.pdf) - Accelerated foreign private issuers
- Proposed Release 33-8731 (http//www.sec.gov/rul
es/proposed/2006/33-8731.pdf) - Non-accelerated filers
- Newly public companies
- Obtain additional feedback (Concept Release)
- Issue guidance on management assessments
- Work in concert with PCAOB (standard setting,
inspections)
8404 Compliance Dates (Proposed)
9Rulemaking AgendaDecember 13
- Internal Control Reporting
- Management reporting
- Deferral for non-accelerated filers and newly
public companies - Internet Availability of Proxy Materials (Release
34-52926) - http//www.sec.gov/rules/proposed/34-52926.pdf
- Foreign Private Issuer Deregistration (Release
34-53020) - http//www.sec.gov/rules/proposed/34-53020.pdf
- Exchange Act Rule 14a-8
10Personnel Changes
- New Chief Accountant Conrad Hewitt
- New Deputy Chief Accountant for Professional
Practice Zoe-Vonna Palmrose
11SAB 108 Quantifying Effects of Prior Year
Errors
- Topic 1-N (http//www.sec.gov/interps/account/sab1
08.pdf) - Effects of prior year errors on current year
financial statements - Historical diversity in practice
- Iron curtain vs. rollover approaches
- May require significant adjustments
- Transition
- Restatement not required
- Effective for years ending after 11/15/06
12Assessing Errors
- Are the financial statements materially
misstated? - Identify and quantify errors that have not been
corrected (SAB 108) - Evaluate whether the effects of those errors are
material (SAB 99)
13Rollover Approach
- Focuses on the income statement
- Error is the amount by which the current year
income is misstated - May result in the accumulation of
significant errors in the balance sheet
14Iron Curtain Approach
- Focuses on the magnitude of the error to the
current balance sheet - If a prior year error is corrected in the current
year, does not consider the current year
financial statements to be misstated - May not prevent significant misstatements of
income
15Alternative Approaches Example
- Improper expense accrual of 100 that has built
up over 5 years at 20 per year - Rollover approach - 20 overstatement of expenses
- Iron curtain approach - 100 overstatement of
liabilities and expenses
16SAB 108 Dual Approach
- Evaluate misstatements under both approaches
- If the adjustment would be material under either
approach the error should be corrected
17SAB 108 Dual Approach
- If you correct an error that was immaterial
in prior years but is material to the current
year - Restate prior year financial statements
- But no need to amend prior filings
18SAB 108 Transition Approaches
- Restating is permitted
- Restating is not required if management
- Properly applied its previous assessment approach
- Considered all relevant qualitative factors in
assessing previous errors - Alternative Report cumulative effect as
adjustment to opening 2006 balances (through
retained earnings)
19SAB 108 Example Transition Entries
- Record cumulative catch up entry as of January 1,
2006 - Dr. Liability 80
- Cr. Retained earnings 80
- Correct the remaining 20 misstatement as an
adjustment to 2006 earnings - Dr. Liability 20
- Cr. Expense 20
20SAB 108 Transition Disclosures
- Nature and amount of each individual error being
corrected - When and how each error being corrected arose
- The fact that the errors had previously been
considered immaterial
21SAB 108 Adopt in an Interim Period
- Not required to amend previously filed interim
reports - Disclose the effect on the current period and any
prior periods adjusted - If necessary, restate this years quarters
- Quarterly data in next Form 10-K
- Prior year columns in next years Form 10-Qs
22SAB 108 Adopt at Year End
- Consider SAB 74 disclosures in interim financial
statements - If necessary, restate this years quarters
- Quarterly data in next Form 10-K
- Prior year columns in next years Form 10-Qs
23SAB 108 Other Issues
- IPOs
- Must apply dual approach if the registration
statement is effective after Nov. 15, 2006 - Transition via restatement
- Implementation questions
- Private companies?
- Interim materiality next SAB?
24Stock Option Accounting Overview
- Issues
- Timing practices pricing practices
- Accounting, tax, legal, internal control issues
- Investigations intentional practices, sloppy
practices - Timeframe pre-SOX
- Accounting standard was APB 25
- Intrinsic value at measurement date
- Date the number of options and price are known
25SEC Staff Guidance
- September 19 letter to FEI and AICPA
- Reflects practical/common sense approach
- Available at
- http//www.sec.gov/info/accountants/staffletters/
- fei_aicpa091906.htm
- Topics largely relate to questions about whether
a companys past measurement date determinations
were appropriate
26What if there was an administrative delay in
completing required granting actions?
- It depends. If the company operated
- As if the terms of the awards were not final,
then measurement date did not occur until the
completion of all required granting actions - As if the terms and recipients of awards were
final on an earlier date, it may be appropriate
to conclude that a measurement date occurred
prior to the completion of all required granting
actions
27Is the grant valid?
- If
- The company intends to honor the awards in stock
and - Reasonably concludes that it will be able to do
so - Then
- There is a substantive arrangement that can serve
as the basis of the accounting - Can account for the awards as fixed
- Potential need for legal analysis
28What if the documentation is incomplete?
- It depends
- Dont default to variable accounting or to
treating the awards as if they had never been
granted - Use all available relevant information
29Other Questions Addressed
- What if the individual grant recipients are
uncertain? - What if the exercise price is set by reference to
a future market price? - What if the grant is made prior to employment?
- What if the options were timed to specific
company announcements? - What if the options were changed due to the
release of new information? - What if the incorrect exercise date was
documented to reduce income taxes for the
employee? - What if the Statement 123 pro forma footnote
disclosure is in error?
30Audit Implications
- PCAOB Audit Practice Alert No. 1 Matters
Related to Timing and Accounting for Option
Grants - http//www.pcaob.org/News_and_Events/News/2006/07-
28_Release.pdf - Audit procedures depend on nature and potential
magnitude of risk -
31Other Stock Option Auditing Matters
- PCAOB Staff FAQ Auditing the Fair Value of
Share Options Granted to Employees - Issued October 17, 2006
- http//www.pcaobus.org/Standards/Staff_Questions_a
nd_Answers/2006/Stock_Options.pdf -
32Other SEC Practice Issues
- Cash flows classification
- Non-GAAP financial measures
- Restatements Form 8-Ks
33GAO Study Restatements
- Analyzed 1,392 restatements between July 2002 and
September 2005 - Available at http//www.gao.gov/new.items/d06678.p
df - Number of companies restating financial
statements rose from 3.7 to 6.8 - 17 did not file an Item 4.02 Form 8-K to report
the restatement
34 GAAP Update October 2006
35Agenda
- FASB Statement Nos. 157 and 158
- FASB Staff Positions
- Proposed FASB Staff Positions
- EITF Consensuses
- EITF Open Issues
36FASB Statement No. 157
- Uniform definition of fair value
- Guidance on measuring fair value
- No expansion of areas in which fair value
measurements are required - Effective for fiscal years beginning after
11/15/07
37FASB Statement No. 157
- Guidance on measuring fair value in absence of
active markets differs from - Past accounting guidance
- Typical practice of valuation specialists
- Ideal is perspective of marketplace participant
- Company-specific data a fallback
- Transaction costs excluded
- Blockage adjustment to market prices prohibited
38FASB Statement No. 158
- Defined benefit pension and other postretirement
benefits - Change to balance sheet display
- Fiscal years ending after 12/15/06 for companies
with publicly traded equity - Fiscal years ending after 6/15/07 for others,
including not-for-profits - Requirement to use year end measurement dates
effective for fiscal years ending after 12/15/08
39FASB Statement No. 158
- Todays balance sheet shows asset or liability
equal to cumulative difference between accounting
expense and funding - Amount on balance sheet also equals difference
between obligation and plan assets adjusted for - Unrecognized gains and losses
- Unrecognized prior service cost
- Unrecognized transition obligation
40FASB Statement No. 158
- New requirementbalance sheet asset or liability
equal to difference between obligation and plan
assets - PBO for pensions
- APBO for other postretirement plans
- Unrecognized items shown as elements of
shareholders equity (accumulated other
comprehensive income), net of income tax
41FASB Statement No. 158
- Balance sheet gross up similar in some respects
to additional minimum liability for pensions, but
different because - Measure of obligation is PBO versus ABO
- All unrecognized items displayed in shareholders
equity - Prior requirements showed unrecognized prior
service cost as an intangible asset
42FASB Statement No. 158
- Issues for first application of new balance sheet
guidance - Compliance with contractual requirementsdebt
covenants, bonding requirements, bidding
requirements - Book value stock plans
- Realizability of deferred tax assets associated
with balance sheet liabilities
43FASB Staff Positions--Final
- AUG AIR-1 Accounting for Planned Major
Maintenance - Accrue in advance method no longer acceptable.
Defer and amortize, expense as incurred, or
built-in overhaul method continue to be
acceptable - New in finalalso applies to quarterly financial
statements - FAS 123(R)-5 Amendment of FASB Staff Position
FAS 123(R)-1 - Addresses whether a modification of an instrument
in connection with an equity restructuring or a
business combination should be considered a
modification for purposes of applying FSP FAS
123(R)-1
44FASB Staff Positions--Final
- FAS 123(R)-6 Technical Corrections
45FASB Staff Positions--Proposed
- FAS 126-a Revision to the Definition of a Public
Entity to Include an Obligor for Conduit Debt
Securitiesstill open - EITF 00-19-b Registration Rights Agreements
- EITF 03-6-a Whether employee stock compensation
arrangements represent participating securities
for EPS purposes
46FASB Staff Positions--Proposed
- FAS 141-b, 142-e, and 144-b Transition guidance
on fair value measurements until Statement 157
becomes effective
47EITF Update
SELECTED EITF ISSUES
48Final Consensus
- 06-1, Consideration paid by service provider to
an intermediary rather than to a customer - Is debit revenue reduction or an expense?
- Generally consistent with EITF 01-9 guidance for
consideration paid to customer
49Final Consensus
- 06-4, Endorsement Split-dollar life insurance
- Employer has a postretirement obligation to
employee - Purchase of insurance does not settle the
employers obligation
50Final Consensus
- 06-5, Company-owned life insurance
- Asset should be measured by considering all
consideration that company would receive upon
surrender - Each policy should be measured individually
51Tentative Consensus
- 06-6, Modification of a conversion right
- 06-7, Previously bifurcated conversion right that
no longer needs to be bifurcated - 06-6 would nullify Issue 05-7 consensus
- Two more in long string of EITF issues dealing
with convertible debt - Complex models
- EITF recommendation that FASB give accelerated
consideration to convertible debt
52Tentative Consensus
- 06-8, Buyers continuing investment in
condominium transactions - For seller to use percentage-of-completion
method, buyers continuing investment must meet
Statement 66 requirements - To accomplish, buyer either (1) makes payments to
amortize debt during construction or (2) makes
extra down payment
53Tentative Consensus
- 06-9, Change or elimination in difference in
fiscal years between investor and equity method
investee - Accounting change under FASB Statement No. 154
- Retrospective application unless not practicable
as defined in Statement 154
54Open EITF Issues
- 05-4, Liquidated damages in equity derivative
contractsnow proposed FSP EITF 00-19-b - 06-H, Application of AICPA Broker-Dealer Guide to
commodity traders - 06-I, Joint development, manufacturing, and
marketing arrangements in biotechnology and
pharmaceutical industries - 06-J, Subsequent accounting for executory
contract recorded at fair value in purchase
accounting