Title: INVESTMENT VOLATILITY: ARE ALTERNATIVES AN ALTERNATIVE
1INVESTMENT VOLATILITY ARE ALTERNATIVES AN
ALTERNATIVE?
- Council on Foundations Annual Conference
- April 28, 2003
- Edward B. Kacic, Irvine Health Foundation
- Bruce Madding, Kaiser Family Foundation
- Jim Martin, M.J. Murdock Charitable Trust
2Todays Discussion
- What Well Cover
- Alternatives 101
- Introduce Concepts
- Discuss Types of Alternative Assets
- Discuss Use of Alternatives
- Discuss Benefits and Potential Pitfalls
3Todays Discussion
- What We Wont Cover
- Investments 101
- Basic Asset Allocation
- In-Depth Details of Sub-Strategies
- Sales Pitches for Specific Products
4Glossary What We Mean
- Volatility Standard deviation of returns
- Correlation Coefficient Degree to which assets
move in relation to one another (always expressed
as range of -1 to 1) - Alpha Excess return (e.g., returns that exceed
benchmark)
5Glossary What We Mean
- Beta Sensitivity of an asset/portfolio to the
movement of the market (Market beta equals 1.
Beta of 1.1 indicates asset is expected to move
10 more than the market)
6What Are Alternatives?
- Non-traditional Strategies
- Debt, Equity, and/or Real Assets
- Lower Correlation to Traditional Assets
- Can Contribute to Lower Portfolio Volatility
- Can Contribute to Higher Expected Return
7Types of Alternative Investments
- Commonly Described
- Private Equity
- Private Debt
- Venture Capital
- Absolute Return
- Hedge Funds
- Real Estate
- Natural Resources
- Commodities/Futures
- Well Call Them
- Private Equity
- Hedge
- Real Assets
- Not Discussed Here
8Investment Methodologies
- Direct Investment
- Partnerships
- Funds
- Funds of Funds
9Considerations
- Asset Allocation
- Liquidity
- Finding Appropriate Investments
- Minimum Investment Requirements
10Considerations
- Expected Returns
- Performance Evaluation
- Fees
- Legal Issues
11Types of Alternative Investments
- Commonly Described
- Private Equity
- Private Debt
- Venture Capital
- Absolute Return
- Hedge Funds
- Real Estate
- Natural Resources
- Commodities/Futures
- Well Call Them
- Private Equity
- Hedge
- Real Assets
- Not Discussed Here
12Council on Foundations54th Annual
ConferenceDallas, TexasApril 28 30,
2003
- Investment Volatility
- Are Alternatives an Alternative?
- Jim Martin
- 400 pm 530 pm
- Monday, April 28, 2003
13Discussion
- Jim Martin Background
- M. J. Murdock Charitable Trust
- Overview
- Asset Allocation Policy/History
- Return Expectations/Risk
- Volatility
- Alternatives - Traditional Asset Classes
14Discussion
- Alternatives M. J. Murdock Charitable Trust
- Alternatives Issues to Consider
- Direct or Fund-of-Funds Investing
- Performance Measurement Considerations
- Historical Returns
15Jim Martin Background
- Deloitte Touche
(formerly, Deloitte Haskins Sells) - 18 years
- Partner
- M. J. Murdock Charitable Trust
- 1987 Present
- Chief Investment and Financial Officer
16Jim Martin Background
- Registered Investment Advisor
- Manage Approximately 125 million on Fully
Discretionary Basis - Investment Committees
- Sunkist (200 mil)
- Rasmuson Foundation (425 mil)
- Boy Scouts Cascade Pacific Council (1.2 mil)
- Vancouver Rotary Foundation (1.2 mil)
- Red Cross Clark County, Washington (1.4 mil)
- Community Foundation of Southwest Washington (30
mil)
17M.J. Murdock Charitable Trust Overview
- Private Foundation
- Vancouver, Washington
- 460 Million
- Formation
- Jack Murdocks Estate - 1975
- Tektronix Co-Founder
- Assets at Inception
- 91 million
- Grantmaking
- Five Northwest States
- Cumulative Grants Since Inception 386 million
- Primarily Scientific Research and Education
18M.J. Murdock Charitable TrustAsset Allocation
Policy/History
19M.J. Murdock Charitable TrustReturn
Expectations/Risk
20Volatility
- Volatility
- Not Your Friend
- Career Risk
- Standard Deviations Measurement
- Extreme Volatility
- Any Asset
- Any Investment
- Biggest Risk
- Not Having Dollars When Needed
21Volatility
- Minimizing Volatility
- Multiple Asset Classes
- Asset Class Diversity
- Use Alternatives
- Non-Product Correlation
- Asset Class Return Guarantee
22Alternatives Traditional Asset Classes
- Alternatives Non-Traditional Products
- Not Long Only Bonds or Equities
- Looks Like A Duck Sounds Like a Duck
Alternative - Modeled Risk/Return Characteristics
- Asset Class
- Capital Preservation
- Murdock Trust Example
23Alternatives M. J. Murdock Charitable Trust
- Various Options
- M. J. Murdock Charitable Trust Structure
- Private Equity
- Venture Capital
- Private Placements
- Oil and Gas
- Mezzanine
- Secondaries
- Global
- Distressed Securities
- Hedge Funds
- Other
24(No Transcript)
25(No Transcript)
26(No Transcript)
27(No Transcript)
28(No Transcript)
29(No Transcript)
30AlternativesIssues to Consider
- Liquidity Need
- Cash Flow
- Building the Class and Distributions back
- Commitment Sizes
- 10- to 15-year Product Commitments
- Valuations
- Daily, Monthly, Quarterly, Annual
- Perceptions
- Constituency
- Other Interested Parties
31Direct or Fund-of-Funds Investing
- Invest Direct
- For the Big Boys
- Significant Assets
- Minimum Requirements
- Prudent Diversification
- Diversification
- Type
- Vintage Year
32Direct or Fund-of-Funds Investing
- Fund-of-Funds
- Diversification
- Expertise
- Due Diligence Leveraging
- Fees
33Performance Measurement Considerations
- Private Equity Investments
- Not Marked to Market
- Best Measurement
- IRR?
- Time Weighted Returns?
- Cash Flow Multiples?
- Combination Thereof or Hybrid?
- Combining Alternative and Traditional Asset Class
Return
34Historical Returns
35Historical Returns
36Questions?
37Types of Alternative Investments
- Commonly Described
- Private Equity
- Private Debt
- Venture Capital
- Absolute Return
- Hedge Funds
- Real Estate
- Natural Resources
- Commodities/Futures
- Well Call Them
- Private Equity
- Hedge
- Real Assets
- Not Discussed Here
38What really is a hedge fund?
- The term hedge fund is a catchall that applies
to thousands and thousands of investment funds of
all strategies. A hedge fund can be any limited
partnership thats constructed in such a way as
to give the general partners the managers of
the fund a share of the profits earned on the
limited partners money. -
- - Andy Serwer Carol Loomis, Fortune
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
39Hedge Funds Defined
- Private pooled investment vehicles
- Short positions, derivatives, leverage, hedging,
arbitrage - Normally charge an incentive fee based on fund
performance - Specialized, skill-based alternative investment
strategies - Seek to capitalize on pricing inefficiencies
Source Northern Trust CIS Conference 2001
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
40Why Invest?
- Diversification of equity market risk
- Higher comparative liquidity
- Positive returns in negative market environments
Source Northern Trust CIS Conference 2001
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
41Short Term Performance
Source EIM Group Presentation, The Promise and
the Reality of Hedge Fund Investing
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
42Long Term Performance
Source EIM Group Presentation, The Promise and
the Reality of Hedge Fund Investing
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
43Hedge vs. Greater Market
HFRI vs. Greater Market Indices
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
44Historical Risk/Returns
Source EACM
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
45Steps to develop a hedge fund portfolio
- Articulate your investment beliefs
- Management of complexity
- Understanding all the strategies
- Automation, database management, well-defined
processes - Search for unique sources of alpha
- Undertaking individual manager due diligence
- Advanced Portfolio Construction
- Name, measure and immunize the portfolio from as
many potential shocks as possible - Structuring the portfolio to meet the
organizations risk and return expectations -
- - Northwater Capital Management
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
46Alternative Asset Program Objectives
- Define Objectives of the Program
- Diversification
- Low correlation to equity market
- Low volatility to equity market
- Expected return inflation 8
- AGGRESSIVE
- Outperform broad equity
- market w/ 60-80 of volatility
- Significant directional risk
- CONSERVATIVE
- Low volatility/low return
- Emphasis on diversification
- MODERATE
- Some equity market directional risk
- Volatility 1/3 of equity market
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
47Hedge Fund Categories
- Relative Value
- Long/Short Equity
- Convertible Arbitrage
- Fixed Income Arbitrage
- Market Neutral Equity Arbitrage
- Multi-Strategy Hedge
- Event-Driven
- Deal Arbitrage
- Bankruptcy/Distressed
- Multi-Strategy
- Equity Hedge Funds
- Long Biased
- Opportunistic
- Global/International
- Global Asset Allocators
- Discretionary
- Systematic
- Short Selling
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
48Hedge Fund Spectrum
Hedge funds cover a broad spectrum of risk/return
characteristics
Global Macro
Emerging Equities Managed
Futures Dedicated Short Bias
Market Timing Long/short
Equity Distressed Securities Fixed Income
Arbitrage Convertible Arbitrage
Merger Arbitrage Equity Market Neutral
Return
Low Volatility High
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
49Choosing Appropriate Strategies
Define Objectives of the Program
- Conservative Strategies
- - Distressed Securities (Senior)
- Diversified Arbitrage
- (Low/No Leverage)
- Event Arbitrage
- Market Neutral
- (Broad Market Sectors)
- Moderate Strategies
- Convertible Arbitrage
- Distressed Securities (Post Bankruptcy)
- Diversified Arbitrage
- (Some Leverage)
- Event Arbitrage (Higher Risk Deals)
- Market Neutral
- Short-Biased
- Long/short US Equity (No Leverage)
- Aggressive Strategies
- Global Long/Short
- Global Macro (Leveraged)
- Long/short US Equity (Concentrated Value or
cap-size focus) - Sector Funds
- (Sector Directional Risk)
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
50Kaiser Hedge Allocations
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
51Diversification through Partnerships and Fund of
Funds
Conservative Strategies
Moderate Strategies
Aggressive Strategies
Defined Target Allocations for each strategy (8
to 10 funds total)
Partnership Investments Only
Fund of Funds and Partnerships
Fund of Funds Only
- Achieve Objectives of the Program
- Diversification
- Low correlation to equity market
- Low volatility to equity market
- Expected return inflation 8
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
52Accessing Absolute Return Strategies
- Direct Investment
- Pros Greater Control
- Cons Research intensive, administratively
burdensome, manager cross correlation - Consultant
- Pros Greater diversification, consolidation of
information - Cons Not fully immersed in industry knowledge,
probable manager cross correlation - Fund of Funds
- Pros Low correlation b/w managers, greater
liquidity, low minimum investment increases
access for smaller investors, consolidation of
information, expertise - Cons Higher fees
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
53Due Diligence
- Try to determine whether past performance is
sustainable - Look at stability
- Administration and back office
- Minimum 3 year track record preferable
- Evaluate qualitative ability in judgment
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
54Risks
- Blundered, blown-up or defrauded
- investors at fairly regular intervals
-
- - The Economist
- Chicago Art Institute
- Lipper
- Long Term Capital
- Askin Capital
- Eifuku
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
55Eifuku good fortune?
- Eifuku Master Fund, a 300 million hedge fund,
in Japan is being wound down after losing
virtually all its capital in just seven trading
days in early January. The swift reversal in the
fund, which was up 76 in 2002, shows just how
volatile hedge funds can be. -
-
- - Henny Sender Jason Singer, Wall
Street Journal
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
56Failed Funds
- Overall about 750 hedge funds closed up shop
last year, or about 14 of all funds, up from
11 - - Henny Sender Gregory Zuckerman, Wall
Street Journal
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
57Optimization
- As with real estate and private equity, hedge
funds offer optimization techniques to imperfect
input data for all three parameters, risk, return
and correlation. This is due to infrequent and
sometimes imperfect mark-to-markets, survivor
bias and relatively short return histories. -
- - Northwater Capital Management
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
58Risks
- Whether or not it is a bubble or a gold rush no
one disputes that it is certainly a craze - - Growing concerns that not all the money that
has been raised can be allocated
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
59Risks
- You Cannot Scale Talent
- - Stephen Oxley of Watson Wyatt
- Headline Risk
- No Transparency
- Higher Costs
- Turnover
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
60Fierce secrecy
- My client called up this hedge fund he had a big
chunk of money in to ask generally about its
positions and they basically told him, None of
your business. And it was his money! -
- - Anonymous fund of funds manager
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
61Survey of Pension Plans
Does your plan allocate or intend to allocate to
higher risk strategies like alternative
investments private equity, venture capital, and
hedge funds?
The survey was conducted on 205 investment
officers from corporate, public, and union funds.
12 of funds reporting held more than 10
billion in assets, 42 had 1-9.9 billion, 21
had 500 million - 1 billion, and 25 had 200
million - 499 million.
Council on Foundations April 28, 2003
Source Fidelity Viewpoint, Winter 2003
62Bibliography/Resources
- Pioneering Portfolio Management An Unconventional
Approach to Institutional Investment. David F.
Swensen. The Free Press, 2000. - Hedge Funds Investment and Portfolio Strategies
for the Institutional Investor. Jess Lederman
Robert Klein, editors. Irwin Professional
Publishing, 1995. - The Handbook of Alternative Investment
Strategies. Thomas Schneeweis, Joseph F.
Pescatore, editors. Institutional Investor, 1999.
63Bibliography/Resources
- Evaluating and Implementing Hedge Fund
Strategies, second edition. Ronald A. Lake,
editor. Euromoney books, 1999. - The Money of Invention How Venture Capital
Creates New Wealth. Paul A. Gompers and Josh
Lerner. Harvard Business School Press, 2001.
64Bibliography/Resources
- Journal of Alternative Investments.
Institutional Investor. www.iijai.com. - National Assn. of Real Estate Investment Trusts
www.nareit.com - National Council of Real Estate Investment
Fiduciaries www.ncreif.com
65Bibliography/Resources
- Managed Account Reports www.marhedge.com
- Venture Capital Institute www.vcinstitute.org
- Venture Economics www.ventureeconomics.com