Title: A Statewide Report on:
1A Statewide Report on
PARTICIPATION IN THE ARTS
Prepared for Arts Queensland CB
Contact(s) Sharon Bird Lisa Scott, Colmar
Brunton Research Services Final Report 18th
Sept 2006
2CONTENTS
3Overall Background, Objectives Methodology
4BACKGROUND
- This research was commissioned to help Arts
Queensland build a body of knowledge about the
Arts participation habits and preferences of the
Queensland public. - This research was intended to complement an
earlier report commissioned by the Australia
Council (prepared by Saatchi Saatchi in 2000),
which looked at the Australian publics attitudes
to the Arts and their Arts participation habits.
The Australia Council report proposed that
(within Australia) there are five segments in
terms of Arts Participation, as follows - The Arts Lovers High consumers and/or patrons
of the Arts who could not increase their already
heavy involvement. - The Satisfied Those who are perfectly happy
with the state of the Arts, who have set
participation levels and on this basis will not
increase their involvement. - The Interested Individuals with busy social
lives, who enjoy incorporating some arts
activities in their schedule. This group would
go to the Arts more if it suited their
regime/needs better. - The Disinclined Those who are doubtful about
the personal or social relevance of the arts and
who face strong practical barriers to
participation. They do not have major
attitudinal objections to the Arts and indeed may
value their contribution to society, but do not
view them as a priority activity. - The Disengaged - Individuals who feel no
engagement with the Arts and view them as
personally and culturally irrelevant to their
lives. They are unlikely to develop any
connection with the Arts. - The overarching aim of the current research was
to identify the characteristics, thoughts and
feelings of the Interested and Disinclined
segments in Queensland, as these are the groups
that are most likely to increase participation,
if the Arts can be delivered in a way that
tackles their particular barriers to
participation.
5BACKGROUND
- A two stage research project was undertaken
during the period May-August 2006. - The first stage was 6 focus groups 5 in
Brisbane and 1 in Cairns. The second stage was
an online survey of a representative panel of
Queenslanders. - The specification for the sample included in both
the focus groups and the survey was that
respondents could be identified as being from the
Interested or Disinclined segments as defined in
the Australia Councils 2000 Australians and the
Arts Australia wide survey. - It was also a specification that respondents were
not already heavy participants in the Arts. - The qualitative stage of the project aimed to
profile the characteristics of these segments as
they are particular to Queensland. The discussion
during the focus groups was guided to uncover
whether particular barriers and triggers to
participation in the Arts are experienced in
Queensland and to identify what perceptions or
experiences people have around major arts venues
in Brisbane. - Another aim was to discuss peoples views of
promotional strategies and ticketing for the
arts, as well as looking at how they normally
source information about entertainment. - The major objective of the following quantitative
stage of the research was to confirm and
consolidate the qualitative findings, providing a
stronger basis for inference upon which
strategies for targeted promotion of the Arts in
Queensland could be based. - During the quantitative stage, 429 persons across
five locations in Queensland were surveyed (see
page 10 for sample specifics). - The quantitative survey was designed to probe
further into certain areas - such as use of
information sources or how barriers and triggers
are experienced on a venue by venue basis to
provide more immediately actionable information
that Arts Queensland can use as a basis for
developing strategies to promote the Arts to the
Queensland public.
6RESEARCH AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
- The overall aims of the research were to
- Identify general attitudes towards the arts and
seek to establish how similar Queenslanders
attitudes towards participation in the arts are
to those of the general Australian population, in
order to establish the generalisability of the
Australia wide research findings to Queensland. - Identify gaps in knowledge regarding what Arts
Queensland venues do namely, the range of venues
in existence and the range of arts on offer. - Identify perceived applicability of
events/performances to individuals, particular
age groups or families. - Explore barriers that restrict participation.
- Explore views about what could increase
participation. - A number of objectives were explored in the
qualitative research only. Namely - Identify the effectiveness of current promotional
materials, for example - Are events advertised so as to seem important in
terms of personal identity and development or to
seem culturally (or sub-culturally) relevant? - Is the impression of promoted events that they
are high-brow or that they are accessible? - Are the right aspects of the event emphasised
can people find information important to them? - Elicit suggestions for improving the types of
promotional material currently used in a way that
could combat the barriers to participation
perceived by the various cross sections we
involve in discussion.
7RESEARCH AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
- The specific aims of the Quantitative stage were
- To quantify the breadth and depth of
participation in the Arts by querying
participation in regular spare time activities
and general experience of the arts. - To quantify what sources of information
respondents use to find out about arts events and
to quantify how these sources are used e.g.
specific sections of a newspaper or specific
entertainment radio or TV shows. Also, to
quantify which sources are preferred so that Arts
Queensland can identify the most appropriate
channels to reach these people. - To investigate perceptions of pricing for
different kinds of events to quantify any
misperception about cost, as the perceived cost
of participating in the Arts (or more accurately
whether the Arts offer value for money) emerged
as one of the more significant barriers to
participation during the qualitative stage of the
research. - To investigate how and where people purchase
tickets for the Arts and how they would like to
do so. - To quantify general awareness and attendance at
various venues in Brisbane and in regional
Queensland, amongst these segments. - To assess actual experiences or perceptions of
venues established in Brisbane, versus
perceptions and experiences of venues in Regional
locations.
8OVERALL RESEARCH STRATEGY
Project Planning
The majority of this report is based on the
quantitative stage, as quantitative research
provides inferential power to draw conclusions
about the general population, whereas qualitative
research does not. The qualitative stage
provided findings upon which the quantitative
stage was based. Generally, the qualitative stage
then gave insight as to what lies behind the
findings of the quantitative stage. However, it
happens that differences may still exist between
qualitative and quantitative findings. Where
differences exist they are discussed in the body
of the report. All research is used to interpret
the quantitative findings and to draw final
conclusions recommendations. Where conclusions
are based upon qualitative research - which has
no inferential power it is clearly indicated in
the section header. The conclusions and
recommendations from the qualitative research can
be found in Appendix I.
Qualitative Research Stage 6 Focus Groups 2 x
Interested Segment Brisbane Metro (1 x 18-30yrs
1x 31-60yrs) 3 x Disinclined Segment Brisbane
Metro (1x 18-30yrs 1x31-45yrs
1 x 46-60yrs) 1 x Mix Interested and Disinclined
Regional (Cairns 25-45yrs)
Presentation and Quantitative Survey Development
Online Survey n 429 Sample Specifications 5050
Brisbane Metro Regional QLD Respondents Split
between Interested and Disinclined
Segments Representative Spread of Age, Gender and
other demography
Final Report and Presentation
9Online Survey Sample Breakdown
10SAMPLE PROFILE Total Sample
Total Surveys commenced incl. respondents
screened out 829
11OVERVIEW SAMPLE BREAKDOWN BY SEGMENT
- Proportion of respondents per segment was
balanced between the Regional areas and Brisbane
Metro. - A significantly higher proportion of the
Disinclined segment were in the 30-44 year age
group. - Those who attended more than 3 arts events were
screened out of both stages. - Still, significantly higher proportions of the
Disinclined had attended less Arts events in the
last quarter than the Interested. - Disinclined assigned a significantly lower mean
value to the Arts, in personal life and in
society, than the Interested. - Based on the totality of findings from the
research, we know that certain demographic
factors play a role in segment inclusion and we
suspect that inclusion in one segment or another
is fluid depending on life stage.
12NOTES ABOUT INTERPRETATION
The major aim of the research was to investigate
the Arts participation habits of the Disinclined
vs. Interested segments and to explore the
triggers and barriers to participation
experienced by these segments. However, certain
parts of the report e.g. Use of information
sources and general satisfaction with Arts
venues, explore the data on a region by region
basis, as this split provided a more appropriate
basis for future development of Arts promotion
strategies. Throughout the report, where an area
is explored by region, or segment, the results
have been tested for statistical significance.
Where differences are significant a red circle
is used to highlight this fact
Section 4 looks at awareness of and attendance
at, venues around Queensland. It also deals with
perceptions and experiences of venues around
Brisbane and at a regional aggregated level.
Significant differences are circled in red
EXCEPT where the slide deals with a mixed
positive-negative scale. In this case
significant differences are circled in green
where they are more positive
and in red where they are
more negative. The purpose of this is to try and
distinguish between a significantly more positive
experience/perception and a significantly more
negative experience/perception. This will become
clearer when looking at the charts!
13Key Models from the Qualitative Research
14ARTS RISK MODEL OVERALL STRATEGY
Several major areas of risk which impact on the
decision to participate and general feelings
about the Arts were identified at the Qualitative
stage. Across segments these have varying levels
of influence.
- Financial Risk
-
- Social Inclusion Risk
- Practical Risk
- Enjoyment Risk
Cost risk occurs where there is enjoyment or
social or practical risk involved in participation
e.g. Having the right clothes to wear Not
understanding what everyone is talking about
Being culture specific
LOWEST RISK
HIGHEST RISK
e.g. Being able to find food or parking close by
Having to travel further than for local
entertainment Getting wet.
e.g. Unfamiliarity with the genre or the Subject
matter may not like it or companions may not
like it
Satisfied
Disengaged
Interested
Disinclined
Arts Lovers
Prepared to accept more risk
Prepared to accept less risk
15ARTS AND ENTERTAINMENT RISK MODEL
- Based on the types of risk associated with the
arts and entertainments discussed, the risk model
can be broken into the following four sectors
High Risk, Individual Activity Generally
introspective people may choose to engage in
these alone and they are artistically
challenging. Social risk is high, there is
pressure to understand the message in the display
or the views of the people who are there.
Practical risk may be moderate. Venues accessible
i.e. open during the day and conveniently
located.
High Risk
High Risk, Social Activity Activities in which
people engage to socialise and be highly
entertained. They are probably expensive, they
may be socially elite or have unfamiliar subject
matter. The organiser might feel pressure that
their companions do not like the event. They may
be less practically accessible i.e. unsuitable
timings with limited parking.
Individual Activity
Social Activity
Low risk, Individual Activity Activities in
which people can engage alone. They are free or
cheap to do, are not socially elite and are
practically accessible i.e. open during the day
and conveniently located.
Low risk, Social Activity Activities in which
people engage with a strong social purpose, but
which are free or cheap to do. They are not
socially elite and are practically accessible
i.e. open during the day and conveniently
located.
Low Risk
16ARTS AND ENTERTAINMENT RISK MODEL INCORPORATING
ACTIVITIES
- Based on the qualitative research the risk levels
Queensland respondents associated with different
types of Arts and entertainment or activities
were as detailed below. - These activities and types of venue were then
explored further in the quantitative research.
High Risk
Art Exhibitions
Opera
Exhibition Opening
Ballet
Outdoor Arts Festival
New Media Installations
Theatre
Social
Comedy Show
Individual
Musicals
Rock Concerts
Library
Sports
Volunteer work
Museum
Pub
Low Risk
17Section 1
Regular Pastimes Participation in the Arts
18REGULAR ACTIVITY - TOTAL SAMPLE
Q6. What sorts of things do you do on a regular
basis for entertainment or to pass spare time?
N429
- The overall tendency, identified at both
qualitative and quantitative stages, was for
persons from both segments to participate more in
low risk entertainments or activities. - That is, activities which involve less cost, are
more entertaining than challenging and which
are accessible to a broad cross section of
society, or populist.
19REGULAR ACTIVITY- BY SEGMENT
Q6. What sorts of things do you do on a regular
basis for entertainment or to pass spare time?
N429
- The trend in past time activity is almost
identical between segments. - Although, the Interested segment are
significantly more likely to take part in certain
activities. - In terms of non-Arts activities, the Interested
are more likely to take part in outdoor
activities and go to markets, the cinema or free
events.
20REGULAR ACTIVITY (cont.)-BY SEGMENT
Q6. What sorts of things do you do on a regular
basis for entertainment or to pass spare time?
N429
- This chart also shows how many respondents rated
doing certain activities regularly. - The trend across segments is still similar as
the arts becomes the Arts, participation
across both segments decreases. - However, the Interested segment are significantly
more likely to report taking part in a larger
range of almost all Arts activities on a regular
basis. - This theme was very consistent throughout the
research. - It should be noted that the only activities on
this chart that are not significantly more
participated in by one segment over another, are
Opera, Ballet and art classes.
21ARTS PARTICIPATED IN OVER THE LAST YEAR - BY
SEGMENT
Q7. Please indicate which types of arts events or
activities you have attended or been involved in
over the last year. N429
- Over the last 12 months, respondents from the
Interested segment were significantly more likely
to have participated in an Arts event than those
from the Disinclined segment. - Across both segments, all respondents were more
likely to report having participated in a
populist or low risk arts event than in the
Higher arts. This again is consistent with the
findings from the qualitative research. - However, the proportion of each segment that
reported participating in each kind of Art event
was still relatively low, peaking at 49 for live
band performances in the Interested segment and
dropping to 0 for attendance at Opera in the
Disinclined segment.
Note On this page only NON-significant
differences are marked as the majority of
differences are significant.
22REGULAR ACTIVITY - BY REGION
Q6. What sorts of things do you do on a regular
basis for entertainment or to pass spare time?
N429
- The trend for spare time activity is also similar
across regions. - The only activity that showed significant
difference dependent on region was going to the
cinema, with Brisbane respondents being more
likely to regularly go to the cinema. - From a strategic point of view, segment profiles
are much more relevant therefore, than geographic
location for arts promotion purposes.
23REGULAR ACTIVITY (cont.)- BY REGION
Q6. What sorts of things do you do on a regular
basis for entertainment or to pass spare time?
N429
- Again, across regions, similar patterns were
reported in the arts activities respondents
regularly take part in. - Respondents from the Brisbane area were
significantly more likely to report going to a
museum or art gallery regularly. - Overall, there is no great difference in arts
activity by region, when compared to the sizeable
differences between segments.
24ARTS PARTICIPATED IN OVER THE LAST YEAR - BY
REGION
Q7. Please indicate which types of arts events or
activities you have attended or been involved in
over the last year N429
- Once again, Patterns of participation in the Arts
are highly similar regardless of region. - Only significant differences are marked here.
- The exceptions are attendance at outdoor
festivals and free arts events, which a
significantly higher proportion of regional
residents report attending.
25PASTIMES PARTICIPATION SUMMARY
- There is a significant divergence between the
segments in terms of the arts activities that are
included as part of their regular spare time
activity. This confirms the finding from the
qualitative stage that the Disinclined are less
likely to spontaneously include arts activities
in their list of spare time activities. - The Interested segment are significantly more
likely to have taken part in a broader range of
Arts activities over the last year than those in
the Disinclined segment. This finding also
supports the finding from the qualitative stage
that the Interested were more likely to try out
Arts events even if participation was not a
regular occurrence. - In other words, the depth and breadth of the
Interested segments participation in the Arts
overall is broader than that for the Disinclined.
- At the qualitative stage of the research a risk
model was developed to encompass the factors that
dictate participation in the Arts across the
segments (see Section 5 Conclusions and
Recommendations for a shortened version of this
model). The qualitative stage defined the Higher
Arts Opera, Ballet and Classical Music as
extremely high risk artforms, given that they are
niche and tend to social exclusivity. - Conclusions from qualitative stage were that
those in the Interested segment tolerated a
higher level of risk overall with regards to Arts
participation (i.e. were less susceptible to the
barriers of perception of social elitism, cost,
risk of not enjoying the event) than the
Disinclined segment, as they demonstrated more
positive attitudes to many artforms. However
neither segment would tolerate the high levels of
risk associated with the higher/niche Artforms.
The data collected in the quantitative stage of
the research supports this hypothesis. - With regard to the higher Arts, there is little
divergence between the segments in terms of the
breadth of participation over the last year, or
in regularity of participation. Further, both
segments nominated the higher Arts as something
they did least regularly and the also as the
artforms they had participated in least over the
last year. - Tests for difference between Brisbane Metro data
and Regional Data showed that there is no
difference in the proportion of each segment who
participate regularly, or who have participated
over the last year, in the arts depending on
location. - However, those in a regional areas are
significantly more likely to include outdoor
festivals and free activities in their repertoire
of regular activity, whereas those in the city
are more likely to go to the cinema. Both these
findings may be explained in terms of the
proximity and visibility of these offerings in
the relevant region.
26Section 2
Information Sources for Arts Events
27INFORMATION SOURCES BY SEGMENT
Q8b. Where do you normally find information about
arts events and activities? N429
- Those in the Interested segment are considerably
more likely to access a wider range of
information sources and to gather information
more proactively e.g. they are more likely to
pick up flyers in cafes, see information at
venues they are at already or to seek information
from websites. - This indicates that there are different channels
that could be used to maximise awareness of
events for the different segments. - This divergence in use of communication channels
also applied across Regions.
28PREFERRED INFORMATION SOURCES BY
SEGMENT
Q9. Of these sources, which is your preferred
source or the one you use the most? NNo. who
nominated each source as one they used
INTERESTED
DISINCLINED
- Despite some differences in the breadth of
information sources used by the Interested vs.
the Disinclined segments, there is general
overlap in the sources they would like to use for
arts and entertainment information. - While the Interested are more likely to use
websites to find information, both segments can
be accessed via local papers, radio and
television. In this case, we included
publications like City News and Brisbane News in
Local papers to compile Brisbane Residents
responses. - As shown in the previous slide, word of mouth was
a key information source used by both segments
however the preference for this form of
communication was relatively low.
29INFORMATION SOURCES - BY REGION
Q8b. Where do you normally find out about arts
events and activities? N429
- Regional Queenslanders reported using local
papers, TV and Radio significantly more as
sources of information about Arts and
entertainment, while those living in the Brisbane
metro region reported using email newsletters or
websites more as a source of information. - The differences between regions mirrored the
trends between segments. We found that segment
profiles change slightly in response to the
effect of location i.e. the Metro Disinclined use
more Interested sources and the Regional
Interested use more Disinclined sources.
30PREFERRED SOURCES OF INFORMATION - BY REGION
Q9. Of these sources, which is your preferred
source or the one you use the most? NNo. who
nominated each source as one they used
BRISBANE N216
REGIONAL N213
- The charts above demonstrate the top 5 preferred
sources of information for Arts and entertainment
events by region. The trend for preferred
sources closely mirrors the actual sources
respondents reported using. - For all regions the local paper/ suburban
newspaper is the most preferred method. Brisbane
residents have a greater preferences for sourcing
information from a website, while those in
regional areas have a greater preference for
radio and TV.
31USE OF INFORMATION SOURCES - Television
Q8h. Where do you find information about the Arts
on TV?
52
48
TOTAL SAMPLE N429
54
46
57
43
BRISBANE n92
REGIONAL n114
Significantly more people in Regional areas use
Television to access entertainment information
than those in Regional Queensland. The charts
to the left and right show where (on the TV)
people find the information in question.
BRISBANE n92
REGIONAL n114
32USE OF INFORMATION SOURCES - Websites
Q8f. Which websites do you use for information?
69
31
TOTAL SAMPLE N429
23
77
60
40
REGIONAL n48
BRISBANE n86
Significantly more people in Brisbane use
websites to access information than those in
regional Queensland. Of the websites used, the
charts to the left and right show the top 5
nominated by region. There are significant
differences in the use of certain websites, but
this is clearly due to the location of the events
that are advertised on the relevant websites.
33USE OF INFORMATION SOURCES - Radio
Q8g. Where do you find information about the Arts
on the Radio?
59
41
TOTAL SAMPLE N429
48
52
66
34
REGIONAL n103
BRISBANE n73
Significantly more people in Regional areas use
Radio as a source of information than those in
Brisbane metro. The charts to the left and
right show that there are similar trends in the
way the Radio acts as a source of information
across the regions.
34USE OF INFORMATION SOURCES - Newspapers
Q8h. Where do you find information about the Arts
in the Regional Daily/Courier Mail?
Courier Mail N86
Regional Daily N46
22
40
78
60
35USE OF INFORMATION SOURCES Word of Mouth
From those who said word of mouth at Q10
- There is more use of word of mouth as an
information source for the Interested segment and
within the Brisbane Metro region. It is
currently viewed as one of the most powerful
sources of promotion for a brand or product and
(as a medium conducive to arts promotion) given
its significance amongst channels of
communication about the arts, may be an important
consideration for Arts organisations. - For the Interested segment, word of mouth
information is received equally by face to face/
telephone conversations and by e-mail. For the
Disinclined segment there is slightly more
reliance on word of mouth information being
passed on through face to face/ telephone
conversations. However, once again, there is
more overlap than not.
36COMMUNICATING SPECIAL OFFERS BY SEGMENT
Q10. How would you like to find out about special
Arts event offers e.g. Ticket and meal deals?
N429
- Overall the preference trends for channels of
communication for special offers by segment were
similar. - There were some significant differences in the
proportions of respondents who preferred certain
channels of information. The Interested segment
had a greater preference for e-mail newsletters
and those in the Disinclined segment had a
stronger preference for the local paper, however
this was still the number one preference for the
Interested segment.
37COMMUNICATING SPECIAL OFFERS BY REGION
Q10. How would you like to find out about special
Arts event offers e.g. Ticket and meal deals?
N429
- There were some significant differences in the
proportions of respondents by region who
preferred certain channels of information. - There was a stronger preference for the local
paper and posters or billboards in regional
areas, while Brisbane residents preferred
websites, e-mail or the Courier Mail. - However it should be noted that while Regional
residents had a stronger preference for the local
paper, this was still the most preferred method
for receiving information regarding special
offers for Brisbane residents.
38INFORMATION SOURCES SUMMARY
- There are significant differences between the
segments and the Metro vs. Regional areas in
terms of proactive vs. reactive use of
information sources. - The Interested segment are significantly more
likely than the Disinclined segment to use
several sources for information about arts events
and activities. No one source is exclusively in
use by either segment and across both segments
the Local paper is the primary source of
information. - The Interested segment make significantly more
use of proactive sources of information such as
websites, email, word-of-mouth communication,
finding information at venues, and picking up
flyers in cafes. Of their preferred channels for
communicating special offers email newsletters
and emails from friends both feature. Based on
findings from the qualitative research, this may
be due to these being trusted sources and also
social conduits. - Brisbane Metro residents (similar to the
Interested segment) were more likely to rely on
electronic means of communication and on email
newsletters and websites, whereas those from
Regional areas report using traditional media
significantly more, such as TV, Radio and local
papers. In regional areas people were also
significantly more likely to rely on billboards
or see advertisements outside venues. - In terms of communicating special offers the
Interested segment and Brisbane residents were
significantly more likely to prefer email
newsletters. Whereas the Regional and
Disinclined were significantly more likely to opt
for communication via local papers. - There is some overlay between segment and
location - that is, the Disinclined in Brisbane
Metro are slightly more likely to use electronic
means, whereas the Interested in a Regional area
are slightly more likely to use traditional
sources. This should be a consideration in any
promotional effort that is segment based. - Advertisements accounted for most of the
information all segments received from Radio or
TV. Regional residents report using general
advertisements most but Courier Mail readers
(nearly all Brisbane Metro) were more likely to
use the Weekend Entertainment section. - Ticketek was the most heavily used website across
the Regions. Regional residents were more likely
to use Venue websites for information and people
in Brisbane Metro using generic sites including
OurBrisbane, QTIX and Citysearch significantly
more.
39Section 3
Lead Times, Ticket Purchasing Pricing
40LEAD TIMES TOTAL SAMPLE
Q8a. How long passed between your deciding to got
to the event and your actual attendance at it?
(NSEE X AXIS)
Overall, the stated lead times are fairly short
for most Arts events. The majority of events are
decided upon and attended within three weeks.
There is no difference between segment or region
in terms of lead time. The events that have a
longer lead time are perhaps more costly and
logistically demanding. Lead times are
significant in terms of timing the advertising
relating to these events - see qualitative
conclusions also for more discussion of this
topic.
41BUYING TICKETS BY SEGMENT
Q11b. Once you have decided to go to a ticketed
event how do you normally look for, or obtain,
tickets for it? N429
- The Interested and Disinclined segments generally
purchase tickets from the same sources. - However, there was some difference - the
Interested segment being significantly more
likely to report using third party sales offices
or websites to purchase tickets. - This could be related to the Disinclined having
less familiarity with these sources, thanks to
more limited attendance at events generally, or
to their tendency to attend events
opportunistically.
42PREFERRED TICKET PURCHASE SOURCES TOP 5 - BY
SEGMENT
Q12. How would you prefer to obtain tickets given
a choice? N429
DISINCLINED
INTERESTED
- The trend in preferred ticket purchase sources
closely mimics the trend for actual purchase
sources. - Only the proportion whose preference to use a
third party ticket sales office was significantly
different between the segments, but the overall
proportions who chose to use this source was
still relatively small.
43TICKET PURCHASE SOURCES BY REGION
Q11b. Once you have decided to go to a ticketed
event how do you normally look for, or obtain,
tickets for it? N429
- The trend for purchasing tickets is similar for
across regions, although a significantly greater
proportion of regional respondents called event
specific lines and paid at venues in advance. - This may be related to the higher use of
billboards and posters as a source of information
and to more convenient proximity of venues in
smaller regional centres.
44PREFERRED TICKET PURCHASE SOURCES TOP 5 BY
REGION
Q12. How would you prefer to obtain tickets given
a choice? N429
REGIONAL N213
BRISBANE N216
- The trend in ticket purchasing behaviour is
closely followed by the trend for preferred
ticket purchase sources. - There are some significant differences in the
proportion of regional Queensland and Brisbane
Metro residents who nominate using event specific
websites, but these are still the most preferred
options in both areas. - Significantly more regional residents would like
to pay at the door in advance, again this may be
due to the proximity of venues in regional areas.
While significantly more people in Brisbane
would like to buy tickets from a third party
website, the overall proportion of people who
chose this as an option is relatively small (19
of 216).
45PRICE PERCEPTIONS Over and Under Estimations
- Respondents were asked to estimate what range
they thought the price of a single adult ticket
to certain types of events cost. - The chart above shows the percentage of those who
over and under estimated the price of a ticket
for each type of event. - Results for the Arts are mixed people tend to
over estimate the cost of ballet but
underestimate the cost of Opera. The cost ranges
upon which this finding is based are those
currently published by QTIX. - With the exception of Opera, people are more
likely to overestimate the cost of these Arts
events compared to the cost of more mainstream
activities like football and theme-parks.
46PRICE PERCEPTIONS TOTAL SAMPLE
Q13a. Approximately how much do you think the
cost of a single adult ticket is to the following
events? N429
- For many events, perceptions of pricing are well
outside of the usual price for this type of
event. This may represent a barrier to
participation if people believe this type of
event is outside of their price range e.g. the
Ballet where over 40 of people thought this type
of event was more expensive than it is. - The next page describes a major disparity between
segments in terms of pricing..
47PRICE PERCEPTIONS PROPORTIONS WHO DONT KNOW
PRICE BY SEGMENT
- For all events the Disinclined segment were the
least likely to know the price of the event.
There was no clear difference between the
proportion of Dont knows by Region. - This proportion was significantly larger for the
higher Arts. The significant differences between
segments are all related to events that
Disinclined people are unlikely to have attended
in the last year (we did not question attendance
at ticketed museum exhibitions). - A play at QPAC was the event that had the
greatest proportion of respondents from both
segments who could not estimate a price, despite
the fact that QPAC is a well known venue. - Given low venue attendance this may well be due
to lack of experience with the venue it tells
us that current promotional material may not be
tackling the major barrier of Cost sufficiently.
48LEAD TIMES, TICKET PURCHASING PRICING SUMMARY
- Lead Times
- A significantly higher proportion of respondents
take more than three weeks in lead time where the
event is a ticketed evening time type event.
However, this only relates to musicals,
comedy and live music/Bands. The Qualitative
stage told us that these events were most costly
and popular where a big name was appearing, so
this may account for the longer lead times
despite the general innocuity of these artforms.
There were no significant differences across
segment, or region, in this regard. - Purchasing Tickets
- In keeping with the trend for reactive, rather
than proactive, participation in the Arts, the
Interested are significantly more likely to use
third party ticket websites or sales offices to
purchase tickets, whereas the Disinclined show a
tendency to call event specific phone lines (as
advertised along with the event) or to go to free
events. Advertising specific directions for
obtaining tickets along with events may remove a
practical barrier to participation for the
Disinclined segment. As lower participants in
the Arts, they may not be as familiar with the
existence of services like Ticketek and may also
be less inclined to search for such services to
get tickets. - This trend is mirrored by the Brisbane vs.
Regional segments. Brisbane residents are
significantly more likely to use third party
sales offices than regional residents, who are
conversely, significantly more likely to use
event specific ticket lines. - Event specific websites were the most preferred
source to buy tickets across segments and
regions. This may be related to the qualitative
finding that respondents want one, easy to
access, central, comprehensive source of
information about an event. - Pricing Perceptions
- There was a significant difference in the
proportion of Disinclined respondents who said
they did not know what the ticket price for Arts
events was compared to the Interested segment.
There was no clear difference between Brisbane
Metro and Regional price perceptions. - In the case of Ballet and Opera 29 and 27 of
the sample respectively, did not know what a
ticket might cost. In addition a relatively
large proportion of the sample did not estimate
the price of a ticket within the range of
published prices. Therefore it can be assumed
that the sample generally, but particularly the
Disinclined segment, may experience price
perceptions as a barrier to participation in the
arts.
49Section 4
Venue Awareness, Experience and Perceptions
50Section 4.1Queensland Venues - Awareness and
Attendance
51Brisbane Venue Participation and Awareness
Q Which of the following venues are you aware
of? Q Which of the venues have you been to in
the last year?
Significant diffs. Between segments.
- Attendance at, and awareness of, 36 venues across
Queensland was investigated. The rates of
awareness and attendance, by venue type (combines
Interested and Disinclined), in the Brisbane
Metro area are displayed above. - Although there is relatively high awareness of
three of the venue types tested, there is only
about one third attendance. - Very few respondents knew about or had been to a
Contemporary Arts venue. - Tests on the data showed that significantly
higher proportions of the Interested segment had
been to a Performing or Contemporary arts venue.
There was no segment difference in terms of who
had been to the other venues.
52Regional Venue Participation and Awareness
Q Which of the following venues are you aware
of? Q Which of the venues have you been to in
the last year?
- Attendance at, and awareness of, 36 venues in
total was investigated. Across the Regional
centres the awareness and attendance levels for
the different types of venues was consistent with
the pattern shown across Brisbane Metro venues. - The average levels of awareness of, and
attendance at, each type of venue within the
total sample (combines Interested and
Disinclined) is displayed above. - In keeping with the trend in Brisbane metro,
respondents were least likely to be aware of and
have visited contemporary arts centres than other
kinds of venue. Awareness of and attendance at
Performing Arts centres and Museums was
comparatively high. The gap between awareness
and attendance is largest for Art galleries
only about a quarter of those who were aware of
the galleries actually attended. - Samples were generally not large enough to test
for significance. However, the general trend was
for a higher proportion of the Interested segment
were aware of, and have attended, the specific
venues tested.
53Venue Awareness and Attendance - Summary
- Attendance and Awareness - Regional Differences
- The most striking difference between Brisbane
metro and Regional areas was that although
awareness levels of venues is fairly similar,
significantly more people in Regional areas have
attended certain types of venues. - People in Regional areas make significantly more
use of their museums, performing arts centres and
contemporary arts centres than those in Brisbane.
- However, attendance at, and awareness of,
contemporary Arts venues was still relatively
low. - Attendance at, and awareness of, Art galleries in
both regions was similar. - Attendance and Awareness - Segment Differences
- Due to small sample sizes in some locations
statistical analysis of segment differences was
not possible for venues. However, some trends
emerged from the data which point towards a
difference between the attendance levels of the
Interested and Disinclined. - General awareness of venues tended to be similar
between segments but the Interested were, in most
cases, very much more likely to have attended
venues. - This is reflected in the Interested segments
higher regular participation levels and also to
the finding that they participate in more art
forms on an annual basis than the Disinclined. - It should be noted that in part, the higher
levels of participation at an overall level in
Regional areas is accounted for by the activity
of the Interested segment. - This is an important issue when considering
promotion of the Arts in regional areas. The
barriers to participation in regional areas for
the Interested segment may be partially removed
by the higher visibility of venues and a lack of
other social options when compared to the
Brisbane Metro area. - Any promotion of the Arts therefore, would need
to take account of the already (relatively)
strong presence of this segment at venues in
Regional areas.
54 Section 4.2
Venue Based Participation Barriers and Triggers
55Brisbane Venue Perceptions - Attendees
OVERALL SATISFACTION
MEAN SCORES ON PERCEIVED ATTRIBUTESFOR ALL
BRISBANE VENUES
More Negative
More Positive
POSITIVE ATTRIBUTES
ve Attributes Higher No. Better
NEGATIVE ATTRIBUTES
More Negative
More Positive
- ve Attributes Lower No. Better
- Overall satisfaction with arts venues tested for
Brisbane was quite high (overall mean of 7.4).
The Disinclined gave a significantly lower
overall satisfaction rating than the
Interested, however there was no segment
difference on the other attributes. - Respondents had slightly poorer perceptions of
the facilities at Brisbane arts venues than they
do of staff or value for money, however these are
not significant. - Among those that attended any Brisbane arts venue
in the last 12 months, there was a low agreement
with the statement that the experience was
uncomfortable. - There is a slightly higher agreement with the
opinion that (across all venues tested) those who
attended an event in the last 12 months were not
sure what to do or where to go when they got
there.
56Regional Venue Perceptions - Attendees
OVERALL SATISFACTION
Q Thinking back to when you went to VENUE can
you tell me how much you agree or disagree with
the following statements?
MEAN SCORES FOR ALL REGIONAL VENUES
More Positive
More Negative
POSITIVE ATTRIBUTES
ve Attributes Higher Better
NEGATIVE ATTRIBUTES
More Positive
More Negative
- ve Attributes Lower Better
- Overall satisfaction with the experience at all
regional venues was high, achieving a mean score
of 7.3 and was comparable to Brisbane Metros 7.4
satisfaction rating. - There was a slightly higher perception that the
regional venues have helpful and approachable
staff and provide good value for money than for
Brisbane venues. - Similar to the situation in Brisbane, there was a
low overall perception that experiences at
regional venues are uncomfortable.
57Statewide Venue Perceptions Non-Attendees
Q Can you tell me how much you agree or disagree
with the following statements?
MEAN SCORES FOR ALL VENUES Brisbane v. Regional
MORE POSITIVE
MORE NEGATVE
- ve Attributes Lower No. better
- Respondents were asked how strongly they agreed
with the statements above for a range of venues.
The average score across regional locations for
all venues was compiled, as was the average score
across all Brisbane venues. The diagram above
gives an indication of how strongly these
statements are agreed with in reference to Arts
venues overall in Queensland. - There a several significant, statistical
differences in how venues (generally) are
perceived in Brisbane vs. Regional areas. - In Brisbane, expense and location are bigger
barriers, in Regional areas lack of awareness
about events, not liking the programming or
having a negative perception about the
facility/likely enjoyment of the experience are
more significant barriers.
58Brisbane Venue Perceptions Non-Attendees
Q Can you tell me how much you agree or disagree
with the following statements?
MEAN SCORES FOR ALL BRISBANE VENUES
MORE POSITIVE
MORE NEGATVE
- ve Attributes Lower Better
Disinclined Significantly more likely to agree
with these statements.
- Overall, the Interested and Disinclined agreed
most strongly with the perception that arts
venues in Brisbane are difficult to get to and
from and that they are expensive. - The Disinclined were significantly more likely to
agree with the statement that they were not the
kind of people who went to arts venues and that
they didnt know much about the programming.
59Regional Venue Perceptions Non-Attendees
Q Can you tell me how much you agree or disagree
with the following statements?
MEAN SCORES FOR ALL REGIONAL VENUES
MORE NEGATVE
MORE POSITIVE
- Across all regional venues respondents agreed
most strongly with the statements that related to
lack of knowledge about programming, that there
was never anything interesting on and that they
were not the kind of people who go to art
venues. - The items whose scores are circled in red
indicate statements that the Disinclined agreed
with significantly MORE strongly with than the
Interested did (i.e. they are greater barriers
for the Disinclined). - With the exception of perceptions about cost,
knowledge about/distance to location and previous
experiences, all other factors are more
significant barriers for the Disinclined segment.
60Section 4.3 Performing Arts/Civic Centres vs.
Arts Venues in General
61Brisbane Metro Performing Arts Centre -
Perceptions of Attendees
OVERALL SATISFACTION
Q Thinking back to when you went to VENUE can
you tell me how much you agree or disagree with
the following statements? BASE Attended last 12
months
QPAC
More Negative
More Positive
POSITIVE ATTRIBUTES
ve Attributes Higher Better
NEGATIVE ATTRIBUTES
More Negative
More Positive
- ve Attributes Lower Better
- Those Interested in and Disinclined who attended
the relevant performing arts centre rated
performance on almost every attribute close to
the average level. - However, those who had attended were
significantly more likely to state that they were
not sure what to do or where to go upon arrival
at this type of venue compared to other Brisbane
venues. - This may be related to the relatively lower
attendance levels for this type of venue.
62Brisbane Metro Performing Arts Centre -
Perceptions of Non-Attendees
Q Can you tell me how much you agree or disagree
with the following statements? BASE Aware of
venue, but havent attended last 12 months
- Across the sample, the perceptions most strongly
agreed with were that Brisbane arts venues are
difficult to get to and from, that they were
expensive and that programming is not relevant. - In comparison to the average, respondents in
Brisbane were significantly more likely to feel
that a Performing arts centre would be expensive.
63Regional Performing Arts/Civic Centre -
Perceptions of Attendees
OVERALL SATISFACTION
Q Thinking back to when you went to VENUE can
you tell me how much you agree or disagree with
the following statements? BASE Attended last 12
months
More Negative
More Positive
POSITIVE ATTRIBUTES
ve Attributes Higher Better
NEGATIVE ATTRIBUTES
More Negative
More Positive
- ve Attributes Lower Better
- On average overall satisfaction with the entire
experience at Regional civic centres was
significantly more positive than overall
satisfaction with regional venues generally. - There was also a significantly more positive
perception of helpful and approachable staff at
civic centres compared to regional venues as a
whole. - Meanwhile, transport issues were significantly
less of a barrier for regional civic centres than
other regional venues.
64Regional Performing Arts/Civic Centre -
Perceptions of Non-Attendees
Q Can you tell me how much you agree or disagree
with the following statements? BASE Aware of
venue, but havent attended last 12 months
- There is a significantly stronger perception
that, despite looking, there is never anything
interesting at regional civic centres when
compared to other regional arts venues. - There is also a significantly stronger perception
that regional civic centres are more expensive
than other regional arts venues.
65Section 4.3 Art Galleries vs. Arts Venues in
General
66Brisbane Metro - Art Gallery -
Perceptions of Attendees
OVERALL SATISFACTION
Q Thinking back to when you went to VENUE can
you tell me how much you agree or disagree with
the following statements? BASE Attended last 12
months
BRISBANE ART GALLERY
More Negative
More Positive
POSITIVE ATTRIBUTES
ve Attributes Higher Better
NEGATIVE ATTRIBUTES
More Negative
More Positive
- ve Attributes Lower Better
- Overall satisfaction among those who had attended
a Brisbane Art Gallery was significantly higher
than other Brisbane arts venues. - There was also significantly stronger agreement
that there were helpful and approachable staff
and quality facilities than for other Brisbane
Metro arts venues.
67Regional Art Gallery -
Experience of Attendees
OVERALL SATISFACTION
Q Thinking back to when you went to VENUE can
you tell me how much you agree or disagree with
the following statements? BASE Attended last 12
months
More Positive
More Negative
POSITIVE ATTRIBUTES
ve Attributes Higher Better
NEGATIVE ATTRIBUTES
More Negative
More Positive
- ve Attributes Lower Better
- There was no statistical difference in the
experience of regional art galleries compared to
the average for other regional arts venues.
68Brisbane Metro - Art Gallery -
Perceptions of Non-Attendees
Q Can you tell me how much you agree or disagree
with the following statements? BASE Aware of
venue, but havent attended last 12 months
BRISBANE - ART GALLERY
- Among those who have not attended this venue type
over the last year, there is significantly higher
awareness of its location, than there is of
other Arts venues in Brisbane. - An Art Gallery is also significantly less likely
to be perceived as expensive compared to the
other arts venues in Brisbane. - There is, however, a stronger perception that
respondents friends/family wouldnt attend with
them, that they are not they type of person who
goes to an Art Gallery and that they dont know
much about the shows / events there, compared to
other arts venues in Brisbane.
69Regional Art Gallery
Perceptions of Non-Attendees
Q Can you tell me how much you agree or disagree
with the following statements? BASE Aware of
venue, but havent attended last 12 months
- Across both segments in regional areas, there was
significantly less agreement with the statement
that I look, but never see anything interesting
(at the Art Gallery) when compared to other
regional arts venues. - However, there is a perception that regional art
galleries are less child friendly than other
regional arts venues.
70Section 4.4 Libraries vs. Arts Venues in
General
71Regional Library Awareness and Attendance
Q Which of the following venues are you aware
of? Q Which of the venues have you been to in
the last year?
- The range of awareness of, and attendance at,
Regional libraries is indicated above.
Insufficient data was collected to make a
comparison to Brisbane Metro. - Use of Regional libraries was high when compared
to other types of venue.
72Regional Library - Perception of Attendees
OVERALL SATISFACTION
Q Thinking back to when you went to VENUE can
you tell me how much you agree or disagree with
the following statements?
MEAN SCORES FOR ALL BRISBANE VENUES
More Positive
More Negative
POSITIVE ATTRIBUTES
ve Attributes Higher Better
NEGATIVE ATTRIBUTES
More Positive
More Negative
- ve Attributes Lower Better
- Overall satisfaction with regional libraries was
quite high, at an overall mean of 8.0. - There was also a very strong intent to re-use the
library, and a high opinion of the helpfulness
and approachability of staff. - Despite the high overall satisfaction with the
library, there was a slightly poorer perception
of the library facilities. - There was no statistical difference between the
segments on these attributes.
73Regional Library Perception of Non-Attendees
Q Can you tell me how much you agree or disagree
with the following statements? BASE Aware of
venue, but havent attended last 12 months
REGIONAL LIBRARIES
MORE POSITIVE
MORE NEGATVE
- Combined perceptions of regional libraries are
generally positive. - There is, however, a strong negative perception,
for respondents overall, that they do not have
much in common with people who use the library. - There was no statistical difference between the
segments on these attributes.
74Section 4.5Venue Summary
75Increasing Venue Attendance Summary
- Generally, the aim for Queensland venues is to
increase traffic. - There were no particular points of
dissatisfaction with the venues investigated, as
demonstrated by the generally high satisfaction
levels reported. Although, there are some
specific barriers associated with specific venue
types (e.g. performing arts is more expensive)
these are perhaps, expected perceptions. - This suggests that venues (generally) need to
concentrate on emphasising and developing
triggers to participation. Triggers to
participation were investigated at the
Qualitative stage of the research. - From the Qualitative research it was concluded
that (see qualitative conclusions and profiles) - The Interested were motivated to participate when
the arts option was more exciting/interesting/wort
hwhile than the other entertainment options open
to them and when it offered a way to combine
social obligations i.e. the need to spend time
with family and friends. - The Disinclined were more motivated to
participate when the arts event was something
they could not miss. For those with children
this might be a (free) educational opportunity,
or for those without, it might be a guaranteed
good event. - Both segments, for these reasons, emphasised the
need for clear promoti