Title: Ubiquitous SIP
1Ubiquitous SIP
- Henning Schulzrinne
- (with Knarig Arabshian, Stefan Berger, Stelios
Sidiroglou, Kundan Singh, Xiaotao Wu, Weibin Zhao
and the RPIDS authors) - Columbia University IRT Lab
- TU Darmstadt/NEC/U Karlsruhe/NSF RI/Nokia
December 2003
2Overview
- What is ubiquitous computing?
- Core ubiquitous communications functionality
- Brief introduction to SIP
- Ubiquitous computing in SIP and SLP
- On-going work at Columbia
3What is ubiquitous computing?
- Ubiquitous computing has as its goal the
enhancing computer use by making many computers
available throughout the physical environment,
but making them effectively invisible to the
user. (Weiser, 1993) - Ubiquitous computing is not virtual reality, it
is not a Personal Digital Assistant (PDA) such as
Apple's Newton, it is not a personal or intimate
computer with agents doing your bidding. Unlike
virtual reality, ubiquitous computing endeavers
to integrate information displays into the
everyday physical world. It considers the nuances
of the real world to be wonderful, and aims only
to augment them. (Weiser, 1993)
4Ubiquitous computing aspects
- Also related to pervasive computing
- Mobility, but not just cell phones
- Computation and communications
- Integration of devices
- borrow capabilities found in the environment ?
composition into logical devices - seamless mobility ? session mobility
- adaptation to local capabilities
- environment senses instead of explicit user
interaction - from small dumb devices to PCs
- light switches and smart wallpaper
5Components of ubiquitous communications
- Service discovery ? discover devices
- Service mobility ? configuration information
moves to new devices - Event notification ? for context awareness
- Context-awareness ? location, user actions,
location properties,
6Example ubicomp projects
- Ambient Devices
- EU IST Disappearing Computer
- Project Aura, CMU ? user attention
- UNC office of real soon now
- augmented surfaces Reki99
- Microsoft Easy Living
- Oxygen, MIT
- Portolano, Univ. of Washington
- Endeavour, Berkeley
- CoolTown, HP Labs
7Ubiquitous computing using SIP whats different?
- Traditionally, focus on closed environments (lab,
single company, home, ) - Often, proprietary protocols ? self-contained
environment - Here,
- operate across Internet (? no Corba)
- trusted, semi-trusted and untrusted participants
- use standard protocol mechanisms where possible
- make minimal assumptions on homogeneity
- respect user privacy
8What is SIP?
- Session Initiation Protocol ? protocol that
establishes, manages (multimedia) sessions - also used for IM, presence event notification
- uses SDP to describe multimedia sessions
- Developed at Columbia U. (with others)
- Standardized by IETF, 3GPP (for 3G wireless),
PacketCable - About 60 companies produce SIP products
- Microsofts Windows Messenger (4.7) includes SIP
9Basic SIP message flow
10SIP trapezoid
11SIP event notification
- Named events
- Typically, used for events within conferences
(Alice joined) and call legs (e.g., call
transfer) - Supports arbitrary notification bodies, typically
XML
SUBSCRIBE sipalice_at_vmail.example.com SIP/2.0 To
ltsipalice_at_example.comgt From ltsipalice_at_example.c
omgttag78923 Call-Id 1349882_at_alice-phone.example
.com Contact ltsipalice_at_alice-phone.example.comgt
NOTIFY sipalice_at_alice-phone.example.com
SIP/2.0 Event message-summary Subscription-Stat
e active Messages-Waiting yes Message-Account
sipalice_at_vmail.example.com Voice-Message 2/8
(0/2)
12SIP event architecture
- Does not try to route notifications (application
layer multicast) as in SIENA - Filtering at PA under discussion (for
low-bandwidth devices) - rate
- content
- But most ubicomp notification groups are probably
small - and message volume not likely to provide much
bandwidth saving via network-based filtering - Greatly simplifies trust model no intermediaries
that need to inspect content - can encrypt via S/MIME
- However, can build redistribution exploders and
list subscriptions (subscribe to
engineering_at_hp.com)
13SIP presence architecture
REGISTER
SUBSCRIBE
watcher
PA
Alice
NOTIFY
Bob
lt?xml version"1.0" encoding"UTF-8"?gt ltppresence
xmlnsp"urn" entity"presalice_at_example
.com"gt ltptuple id"sg89ae"gt ltpstatusgt
ltpbasicgtopenlt/pbasicgt lt/pstatusgt
ltpcontactgttel09012345678lt/pcontactgt lt/ptuplegt
lt/ppresencegt
PUAs
PUBLISH
14Session mobility
- Walk into office, switch from cell phone to desk
phone - call transfer problem ? SIP REFER
- related problem split session across end devices
- e.g., wall display desk phone PC for
collaborative application - assume devices (or stand-ins) are SIP-enabled
- third-party call control
15Session mobility via 3PCC
pc42
INVITE speakerphone maudio cpc42
192.0.2.1
INVITE pc42 mvideo c192.0.2.7 maudio c192.0.2.
1
INVITE display mvideo cpc42
192.0.2.7
16How to find services?
- Two complementary developments
- smaller devices carried on user instead of
stationary devices - devices that can be time-shared
- large plasma displays
- projector
- hi-res cameras
- echo-canceling speaker systems
- wide-area network access
- Need to discover services in local environment
- SLP (Service Location Protocol) allows querying
for services - find all color displays with at least XGA
resolution - slp//example.com/SrvRqst?public?typeprinter
- SLP in multicast mode
- SLP in DA mode
- Need to discover services before getting to
environment - is there a camera in the meeting room?
- SLP extension find remote DA via DNS SRV
17Service Location Protocol (SLP)
- Version 2 standardized June 1999
SrvRqst
SA
UA
SA
SrvRply
SrvReg
DA
SrvReg
SrvRqst
DAAdvert
18SLP attribute example
URL serviceprinterlpr//igore.wco.ftp.com/draft
scope-list Development
Language tag en
Attributes (NameIgore),(DescriptionFor developers only), (ProtocolLPR),(location-description12th floor), (OperatorJames Dornan \3cdornan_at_monster\3e), (media-sizena-letter),(resolutionres-600),x-OK
19Other service location mechanism
- DNS SRV/NAPTR
- DNS TXT records (Apple Rendezvous) ? DNS-SD
- UPnP uses SSDP
- multicast HTTP over UDP
M-SEARCH HTTP/1.1 S uuidijklmnop-7dec-11d0-a76
5-00a0c91e6bf6 Host 239.255.255.250reservedSSDPp
ort Man "ssdpdiscover ST gefridge MX
3 HTTP/1.1 200 OK S uuidijklmnop-7dec-11d0-a765
-00a0c91e6bf6 Ext Cache-Control no-cache"Ext",
max-age 5000 ST gefridge USN
uuidabcdefgh-7dec-11d0-a765-00a0c91e6bf6 AL
ltblenderixlgtlthttp//foo/bargt
20Service mobility
- Allow access to service parameters anywhere
payphone problem - address book
- incoming call rules
- source name (SIP From)
- Existing solutions
- SIM card ? cumbersome to change
- synchronization (e.g., Palm) ? not suitable for
borrowed devices - Server-based services ? easier with SIP
(service-routing), if carrier allows - Emerging solutions for SIP systems
- Small user token (smart card, RFID, i-button)
identifying user - Temporarily download configuration from home
server
21Context-based communication services
- Observable state and actions
- State
- location of users
- user activities
- Derive state from
- sensors (time, location, environment, user
interaction) - data (calendars, address books)
- network inputs (messages)
- Actions
- incoming and outgoing calls
- incoming and outgoing IMs, SMS, email,
- Initially, focusing on location at key context
22Location-based services
- Finding services based on location
- physical services (stores, restaurants, ATMs, )
- electronic services (media I/O, printer, display,
) - not covered here
- Using location to improve (network) services
- communication
- incoming communications changes based on where I
am - configuration
- devices in room adapt to their current users
- awareness
- others are (selectively) made aware of my
location - security
- proximity grants temporary access
- Privacy rules for access to context data
23Location-based services
- Presence-based approach
- UA publishes location to presence agent (PA)
- becomes part of general user context
- other users (human and machines) subscribe to
context - call handling and direction
- location-based anycast (anybody in the room)
- location-based service directory
- Languages for location-based services
- building on experience with our XML-based service
creation languages - CPL for user-location services
- LESS for end system services
24Location-based SIP services
- Services
- Location-aware call routing
- do not forward call if time at callee location
is 11 pm, 8 am - only forward time-for-lunch if destination is on
campus - contact nearest emergency call center
- do not ring phone if Im in a theater
- send delivery_at_pizza.com to nearest branch
- Location-based events
- subscribe to locations, not people
- Alice has entered the meeting room
- subscriber may be device in room ? our lab stereo
changes CDs for each person that enters the room - Person location events
- Were implementing SIP, caller-preferences and
CPL extensions for these services
25Locations
- Geographic location
- latitude, longitude, altitude, velocity, heading
- Civil location (? postal location!)
- time zone, street address, city
- some countries are a bit difficult
- Categorical
- office, library, theater, hospital,
- Behavioral
- public location, don't expect privacy
- silence is encouraged, don't ring the phone
26Determining locations
- SIP entities are often far away from physical
user or his current network (intentionally) - For many devices, cant afford hardware to
determine location - different precision requirements
- in Fayette County (within driving distance of
service or person) - on campus
- in room 815
- in corner, talking to Bob
- GPS doesnt work indoors, but Assisted GPS
(A-GPS) may - Use location beacons BlueTooth, 802.11
- may not offer network connectivity
- see our 7DS project offer local content
location - Physically close by network entities
- DHCP (same broadcast domain)
- PPP (tail circuit)
- Not always true with VPNs, but end system knows
that its using a VPN
27Determining location
- Two types of sensors
- end system determines location
- handset-based ? GPS, 802.11 triangulation
- network conveys location to end system or other
component - MAC backtracking
- AP-based 802.11 triangulation
- swipe cards, iButtons, active badges
- Two modes
- explicit user action swipe card, touch iButton
- involuntary network-based tracking
- GPS may not be practical (cost, power, topology)
- Add location beacons
- extrapolate based on distance moved
- odometer, pedometer, time-since-sighting
- idea meet other mobile location beacons
- estimate location based on third-party
information
28Determining locations
- For many devices, cant afford hardware to
determine location - Implementing BlueTooth-based location sensor
networks - CU 7DS project offer local content location
- Developing programmable active badges with IR and
RF capabilities
29DHCP for locations
- modified dhcpd (ISC) to generate location
information - use MAC address backtracing to get location
information
30DHCP for locations
- Proposal DHCP extensions for geographic and
civil location - geographic resolution (bits), long/lat, altitude
(meters or floors) - civil
- what end system, switch or DHCP server
- hierarchical subdivisions, from country to
street, landmark name, occupant - Also, some LAN switches broadcast port and switch
identification - CDP for Cisco, EDP for Extreme Networks
- Can also use backtracking via SNMP switch tables
- locally implemented for emergency services (Perl
sip-cgi script)
31Location-based services SIP
- Were using SIP (and SIMPLE) as generic protocols
for - effecting change (actuators)
- send MESSAGE to devices
- distributing event information (sensors)
- Advantages
- people and rooms identified by URIs
- siphgs_at_cs.columbia.edu
- sipcepsr815_at_cs.columbia.edu
- cross-domain, with extensive security mechanisms
- domains dont need to trust each other
- scalable to global system
- many other systems are mostly local
32Architectures for (geo) information access
- Claim all using protocols fall into one of these
categories - Presence or event notification
- circuit-switched model
- subscription binary decision
- Messaging
- email, SMS
- basically, event notification without (explicit)
subscription - but often out-of-band subscription (mailing list)
- Request-response
- RPC, HTTP also DNS, LDAP
- typically, already has session-level access
control (if any at all) - Presence is superset of other two
33SIP extensions for location-based services
- Location information is highly sensitive
- complete tracking of person
- stalkers and burglars would kill for this
information - IETF GEOPRIV principle target can control
dissemination of location information - restrict time of day, information (location,
heading, velocity) resolution, number of times
queried, destination, retention, - Alice is in time zone MET may be ok for
strangers, but Alice is at 41.872833 N,
087.624417 W, heading NE at 45 mph is not - GEOPRIV still defining application scenarios
- in many cases, easiest to include location
information in-band with protocol, as this
avoids delegating authorization - otherwise, need to give access key to database to
recipient - we propose adding SIP Location header field
34RPIDS rich presence data
- Basic IETF presence (CPIM) only gives you
- contact information (SIP, tel URI)
- priority
- open or closed
- Want to use presence to guide communications
watcher
everything
PA
PUA
watcher
"vague"
PUBLISH
watcher
NOTIFY
CPL
INVITE
35Aside SIP caller preferences
- SIP core philosophy many devices, one identifier
- Address people, not plastic
36Aside SIP caller preferences
- But caller sometimes has preferences among
devices - SIP caller guides call routing
- I hate voicemail!
- I hate people!
- I prefer voicemail
- Multilingual lines
- Caller proposes, callee disposes
sipisabel_at_a.comlanguages"es" sipisabel_at_a.coml
anguages"en"q0.2
INVITE sipsales_at_a.com Accept-Contact
languages"en"
REGISTER
INVITE
sipbob_at_a.comlanguages"en"
37RPID Rich presence data
- Integrates caller preferences information into
presence announcements - ltactivitygt on-the-phone, away, appointment,
holiday, meal, meeting, steering, in-transit,
travel, vacation, busy, permanent-absence - ltplacetypegt home, office, public
- ltprivacygt public, private, quiet
- ltfromgt, ltuntilgt status validity
- ltidlegt activity for device
- ltrelationshipgt family, associate, assistant,
supervisor - ltclassgt grouping
38RPID example
- lttuple id"7c8dqui"gt
- ltstatusgt
- ltbasicgtopenlt/basicgt
- ltcontactgtsipsecretary_at_example.comlt/contactgt
- ltcapcapabilitiesgt ltcapfeature
name"Media"gt - ltcapvaluegtvoicelt/capvaluegt
- ltcapvalue negated"true"gtmessagelt/capval
uegt - lt/capfeaturegt
- lt/capcapabilitiesgt
- lt/statusgt
- lteprelationshipgtassistantlt/eprelationshipgt
- ltnotegtMy secretarylt/notegt
- lt/tuplegt
39Event filtering
- Events are core attribute of ubiquitous computing
systems - tell devices about people actions
- tell people about device presence
- e.g., Alice has entered Room 815
- devices that know Alices preferences subscribe
to Alice - locations may also have presence
- e.g., for occupancy sensors, switches
40Location filtering language
- SIP presence information will be updated using
REGISTER and UPDATE - Need to constrain
- who is allowed to see what detail ? presentity
privacy - who wants to see what detail
- how often
- what granularity of change
- Proposal to allow SUBSCRIBE to include frequency
limitation - Working on CPL-like language invoked (logically)
at publication time - classes of users, e.g., based on entry in my
address book - classes get mapped to restriction
- 12 bits of long/lat resolution, 6 bits of
altitude resolution, 0 bits of velocity - time zone only, category only
- watchers can then add filters that restrict the
delivery - location difference gt threshold
- entering or leaving certain area
- entering or leaving category or behavioral type
41Presence model
SUBSCRIBE
subscription policy
subscriber (watcher)
for each watcher
event generator policy
subscriber filter rate limiter
change to previous notification?
NOTIFY
42Policy rules
- There is no sharp geospatial boundary
- Presence contains other sensitive data (activity,
icons, ) and others may be added - Example future extensions to personal medical
data - only my cardiologist may see heart rate, but
notify everybody in building if heart rate 0 - Thus, generic policies are necessary
43Presence/Event notification
- Three places for policy enforcement
- subscription ? binary
- only policy, no geo information
- subscriber may provide filter ? could reject
based on filter (sorry, you only get
county-level information) ? greatly improves
scaling since no event-level checks needed - notification ? content filtering, suppression
- only policy, no geo information
- third-party notification
- e.g., event aggregator
- can convert models gateway subscribes to event
source, distributes by email - both policy and geo data
44Columbia SIP servers (CINEMA)
Telephone switch
Local/long distance 1-212-5551212
rtspd media server
Quicktime
Single machine
RTSP
sipconf Conference server
RTSP clients
Department PBX
sipum Unified messaging
Internal Telephone Extn 7040
713x
sipd Proxy, redirect, registrar server
SQL database
SIP/PSTN Gateway
Web based configuration
SNMP (Network Management)
Extn 7134
H.323
Extn 7136
siph323 SIP-H.323 translator
NetMeeting
xiaotaow_at_cs
45Location-based services in CINEMA
- Initial proof-of-concept implementation
- Integrate devices
- lava lamp via X10 controller ? set personalized
light mood setting - Pingtel phone ? add outgoing line to phone and
register user - painful needs to be done via HTTP POST request
- stereo ? change to audio CD track based on user
- Sense user presence and identity
- passive infrared (PIR) occupancy sensor
- magnetic swipe card
- ibutton
- BlueTooth equipped PDA
- IRRF badge (in progress)
- RFID (future)
- biometrics (future)
46Example user-adaptive device configuration
all devices that are in the building RFC 3082?
SLP
802.11 signal strength ? location
device controller
REGISTER To 815cepsr Contact alice_at_cs
PA
HTTP
SUBSCRIBE to each room
tftp
- discover room URI
- REGISTER as contact for room URI
SIP
SUBSCRIBE to configuration for users currently in
rooms
room 815
47CINEMA system
48All-SIP implementation
49Service creation
- Promise of faster service creation
- traditionally, only vendors (and sometimes
carriers) - learn from web models
programmer, carrier end user
network servers SIP servlets, sip-cgi CPL
end system VoiceXML VoiceXML (voice), LESS
50sip-cgi
- web common gateway interface (cgi)
- oldest (and still most commonly used) interface
for dynamic content generation - web server invokes process and passes HTTP
request via - stdin (POST body)
- environment variables ? HTTP headers, URL
- arguments as POST body or GET headers
(?arg1var1arg2var2) - new process for each request ? not very efficient
- but easy to learn, robust (no state)
- support from just about any programming language
(C, Perl, Tcl, Python, VisualBasic, ...) - Adapt cgi model to SIP ? sip-cgi
- RFC 3050
51sip-cgi examples
- Block _at_vinylsiding.com
- if (defined ENVSIP_FROM ENVSIP_FROM
"sip_at_vinylsiding.com") - print "SIP/2.0 600 I can't talk right
now\n\n" -
- Make calls from boss urgent
- if (defined ENVSIP_FROM ENVSIP_FROM
/sipboss_at_mycompany.com/) - foreach reg (get_regs())
- print "CGI-PROXY-REQUEST reg SIP/2.0\n"
- print "Priority urgent\n\n"
-
52Call Processing Language (CPL)
- XML-based language for processing requests
- intentionally restricted to branching and
subroutines - no variables (may change), no loops
- thus, easily represented graphically
- and most bugs can be detected statically
- termination assured
- mostly used for SIP, but protocol-independent
- integrates notion of calendaring (time ranges)
- structured tree describing actions performed on
call setup event - top-level events incoming and outgoing
53CPL
- Location set stored as implicit global variable
- operations can add, filter and delete entries
- Switches
- address
- language
- time, using CALSCH notation (e.g., exported from
Outlook) - priority
- Proxy node proxies request and then branches on
response (busy, redirection, noanswer, ...) - Reject and redirect perform corresponding
protocol actions - Supports abstract logging and email operation
54CPL example
55CPL example
- lt?xml version"1.0" ?gt
- lt!DOCTYPE call SYSTEM "cpl.dtd"gt
- ltcplgt
- ltincominggt
- ltlookup source"http//www.example.com/cgi-bin
/locate.cgi?userjones" - timeout"8"gt
- ltsuccessgt
- ltproxy /gt
- lt/successgt
- ltfailuregt
- ltmail url"mailtojones_at_example.comSubjec
tlookup20failed" /gt - lt/failuregt
- lt/lookupgt
- lt/incominggt
- lt/cplgt
56CPL example anonymous call screening
- ltcplgt
- ltincominggt
- ltaddress-switch field"origin" subfield"user"gt
- ltaddress is"anonymous"gt
- ltreject status"reject"
- reason"I don't accept anonymous calls" /gt
- lt/addressgt
- lt/address-switchgt
- lt/incominggt
- lt/cplgt
57Service creation a comparison
API servlets sip-cgi CPL
language-independent no Java only yes own
secure no mostly can be yes
end user service creation no yes power users yes
GUI tools no no no yes
Multimedia some yes yes yes
call creation yes no no no
58Service creation for presence services
(work-in-progress)
- Accept or deny subscriptions
- Shape presence notifications
- different level of detail for family, friends and
colleagues - particularly important for geo data
- Subscriber can filter detail
- primarily, wireless bandwidth constraints
- rate limit notifications
- XPath?
- Mostly, condition/reaction ? CPL can be extended
to most of these functions
59Pushing context-sensitive data to users
- User with mobile device should get location
information when entering city, campus or
building - flight and gate information
- maps and directions
- local weather forecast
- special advisories (choose security checkpoint
2) - Often does not require knowing user
- but interface with (e.g.) calendar
- Example Columbia implementation
- OBEX data exchange over BlueTooth
- PDA pushes current appointment or event name
- base station delivers directions and map
60Conclusion
- SIP auxiliary protocols supports many of the
core requirements for ubiquitous computing and
communications - mobility modalities terminal, user, session,
service - service negotiation for devices with different
capabilities - automatic configuration and discovery
- with SLP or similar
- event notification and triggered actions
- automatic actions event filtering, CPL, LESS
(for end system services) - SIP offers a loosely-coupled approach (cf. Jini
or object models) - Also need data push functionality
- Avoid tendency to assume SIP users are human
want to interconnect different components and
devices - SIP device configuration needs automation, rather
than screen-scraping