Title: Family Chapter 18 Traditional Image of Family The
1FamilyChapter 18
2Traditional Image of Family
- The traditional image of the ideal American
family is a monolithic image in which the family
is - Rigidly nuclear.
- Suburban Middle class.
- Traditional gender roles.
- This image was idealized in 1950s and 60s TV
shows like Ozzie Harriet and Leave it to
Beaver. The reality is that only about 10 of
American families fit this image. American
families are actually very diverse.
3Basic Concepts
- Kinship social relationships based on blood,
marriage, or adoption. - Family a relative permanent social group of 2 or
more people who share a kinship. - Some qualify this definition to add that, in
addition to the above, these people live
together. - Note Social conservatives typically view family
in much more narrow terms. They see it as a legal
marriage between a man and a woman. Social
liberals disagree, arguing that we need a more
inclusive definition of the concept.
4Basic Concepts
- Family of origin the family one is born into.
- Family of procreation the family one forms,
typically to have kids. - Marriage a socially approved mating arrangement
that is expected to be relatively permanent.
5The Family in Cross-Cultural Perspective
- While all societies recognize families, they do
not do family the same way. - Industrial societies tend to favor the nuclear
family. This is where there are only the parents
and the children (and pets) living under one
roof. - Non-industrial societies tend to favor the
extended family.This is where the parents and
kids live with or very close to other kinfolk. - The Americans tend to favor the nuclear family,
but this is mainly in the middle class. Among the
American lower class, extended families are quite
common. There is much variety in American
families.
6Why are nuclear families so typical of industrial
societies?
7Why Nuclear Families?
- 1. Geographic mobility.
- In industrial societies, work and family are
differentiated institutions. People have relocate
often. - 2. Social mobility.
- Our society is also socially mobile, with a fair
amount of upward mobility on the ladder of
success. - Both geographic and social mobility tend to
weaken extended family ties. Nuclear families are
highly mobile. - 3. American values.
- Another reason is that Americans like
individualism and privacy, and the nuclear family
is a more closed and private family system with
fewer relatives butting in. - 4. The rise of a large middle class brought more
affluence. - Affluence made it possible to afford to live
independently from other kinfolk. Nuclear
families tend to be middle class families.
8Comparison of American and Iraqi
FamiliesAmerican Iraqi
- Romantic love is the basis of marriage.
- Most are nuclear families.
- More egalitarian with democratic authority.
- More exogamy.
- Individualism emphasized.
- Arranged marriage is more common. 50 are between
cousins this promotes clan solidarity. - Most are extended families.
- More patriarchal with elders in authority, more
authoritarian. - Strict endogamy for most.
- Familism (family over individual) is emphasized.
9Marriage Patterns
- Cultural norms regulate whom an individual is
allowed to marry, and these norms vary across
cultures. - Endogamy marriage between people of the same
group or category. - Most Americans are fairly endogamous by race,
religion, social class, and age. We tend to marry
people who are like ourselves, but we are a
relatively free society so this is not so
strictly enforced. - Exogamy marriage between people of different
groups or categories, such as between a white and
a black person, or a Jew and a Christian. - Since the 1960s, Americans are more open to
exogamous marriages by race, ethnicity, sexual
orientation, etc.
10Monogamy Vs. Polygamy
- Industrial societies tend to favor norms of
monogamy one partner has one mate. - Our high divorce rate brings serial monogamy,
where one mate is replaced with another. - Only 1/4th of the worlds societies limit
marriage to monogamy, yet most marriages across
the world are monogamous. This is due to the
expense of having multiple spouses, the similar
ratio of men to women, and the fact that people
seem to like pairing off. - Non-industrial societies have more norms of
polygamy one partner has multiple mates. - Polygyny one man mates with multiple women.
- Polyandry one woman mates with multiple men.
This is fairly rare, given that most societies
are patriarchal.
11Family Authority Patterns
- Patriarchy male social dominance. This pattern
is found all over the world. Most societies are
patriarchal. - Matriarchy female social dominance. This is so
rare that some argue there are no matriarchal
societies in the world. - However there are societies where women are
relatively equal to men. These are egalitarian
societies. - The Americans and Europeans are moving from
patriarchal, the current arrangement, toward
egalitarian authority where men and women share
decision-making together.
12Four Historical Forces that Help Women Toward
Equality
- 1. Industrial Revolution changed standards.
- The new era emphasizes cognition over brute
power, and women are just as smart as men. - 2. Decline of religious codes and the rise of
secular society. - Traditional Christian religion sanctified social
hierarchy. The father was defined as above the
mother, who was above the children. - 3. Decreasing size of the family gave women time.
- 1800 8 children on average. This is burdensome
for women. - 1900 4 children.
- 2000 2.3 children. Women got time for more
pursuits like jobs. - 4. Technology changes like the pill gave women
control. - The pill (1959) gave women control to postpone
pregnancy so they could get educated and get
better jobs.
13History of U.S. Family, Functions, and Economy
Economy
Authority
Structure
Family Functions
Period
Pre-1800s
Agrarian
Patriarchy, religious, women have economic roles.
Modified-extended
Almost everything, including economic functions.
Limited to child-centered and emotional
activities, with father as breadwinner and mother
as caretaker (ideally). Children and women become
sentimentalized women are more sexualized.
1850-1950
Industrial
Patriarchy, more secular, women lost economic
roles.
Nuclear
Declining patriarchy, secular, women in the labor
force.
Post-1970
Post-industrial
Less rigidly nuclear
Dual wage families means some loss of child
rearing functions to day care and schools.
14Changing Images of Family
- 1. Family as Haven. 1850s-today.
- With differentiation of work from family, work
became associated with cold, competitive
conditions while family was linked to a warm
haven of love, especially for the husband
returning home from work. Family expectations
increased. - 2. Family as Fun. 1950s-today.
- Post WWII affluence brought new expectations of
family recreation which raised expectations about
family life as fun times. - 3. Family as Encumbrance. 1960s-today.
- More family conflicts came out in the open. The
rise of a distinct youth culture brought a
generation gap between teens and parents, and
rising feminism increased womens frustration
with patriarchal families. Since the 1960s, we
are a bit more open about the family experience
as a negative experience.
15Four Key Functions of Family
- 1. Socialization.
- The family is responsible for primary
socialization, making it the most influential
institution in society. - 2. Regulation of sex.
- All societies regulate sex, and all have an
incest taboo (a strong more forbidding sex
between certain kin). This taboo helps define
family boundaries while protecting the diversity
of the biological gene pool. - 3. Social placement.
- The family ascribes an immediate social status
for the infant and provides them with a social
identity. - 4. Material and emotional security.
- People in families tend to be healthier and
happier than individuals living alone.
16Courtship in Non-Industrial Societies
- In non-industrial societies, courtship is
considered too important to be left alone to the
two individuals. - This is due to the central economic importance of
the family to survival. - These cultures tend to favor arranged marriages -
marriages set up by the parents, often when the
children are still very young. In this system,
marriage represents an alliance between 2
families more than 2 individuals. - Arranged marriages tend to be relative strong
marriages, largely because the boy and girl share
the same cultural values and attitudes. They tend
to be homogamous. - Homogamy means that the couple have similar
characteristics. Homogamy promotes marital
strength.
17Courtship in Industrial Societies
- With industrialization and growing individualism,
extended families decline and nuclear families
increase. - The rise of personal choice (freedom) means that
the marriage will be between 2 individuals who
choose each other. - Here, courtship tends to be extended, because
they need to get to know each other on their own
terms and they need to select the right
partner. - Another reason for the extensive courtship is
that patriarchal societies tend to expect men to
delay marriage so that they can become
financially established. - In the past, courtship used to be chaperoned by
parents. Today it is frequently a period of
sexual experimentation and exploration of
romantic love between 2 individuals.
18Romantic Love
- Romantic love is largely a Western ideal
associated with the tiny aristocratic class of
past monarchies. Eventually it spread to the vast
rising middle classes of the 19th century,
emphasizing erotic passion as the basis of
marriage. - Before then, the basis of marriage involved
practical and rational considerations, usually
involving considerations of wealth, standing, and
family alliances. - Today Americans are heavily socialized into the
value of erotic romance as the basis of marriage. - About 50 of all songs on the radio are romantic
love songs. - Americans view romantic love as the single most
important element in courtship.
19Romantic Love
- Romantic love emphasizes the non-rational appeal
of erotic passion as the basis of the
relationship, and this can lead to intense
initial bonding. It is the stuff of much poetry. - Romantic love is a non-rational criteria in a
highly rationalized society, reminding us that we
are not that rational. - However, romantic love is highly unstable.
Studies suggest romantic love tends to decrease
over time. Marriages based solely on romantic
love can become unstable. - This helps explain why Americans have one of the
highest divorce rates among stable societies. We
use non-rational considerations as the primary
basis of commitments intended to last a life
time. - Romantic love, sometimes called erotic love, is
one of several types of love, including affection
(family based such as between parent and child
or brother and sister), friendship, and spiritual
love. Often a couple that marries for romantic
love develops these other forms of love,
strengthening their relationship over time.
20Romantic Love
- How is romantic love functional today?
- Industrial societies require a lot of
geographical mobility among the workforce. A
nuclear family bonded by romantic passion
functions to make it easier to leave ones
parents, siblings, and friends behind to pursue a
job. - Given the perhaps over-rationalized nature of our
society, romantic love (and rock n roll) offer a
passionate reminder that we are not machines. We
have feelings and we are free to express them.
21Romantic Love
- How is romantic love dysfunctional?
- Studies of couples that move away from families
and friends to a distant city to get new jobs
reveal that there is an initial increase in the
emotional solidarity of the couple, but that
after a year or so there is a good possibility
that one of the partners will become
overly-dependent on the attentions of the other
and the relationship becomes stressed. - Romantic love brings a high level of emotional
intensity. Consequently, spousal arguments can
breed aggression and violence. The Americans have
a high rate of family violence and divorce partly
for this reason. - Overall, marriages based solely on romantic love
are less strong than marriages based on practical
considerations.
22Homogamy
- The strongest marriages are characterized by
homogamy, where the couple shares similar social
characteristics involving age, social class,
ethnicity, religion, and core values. The more
homogamous the couple, the greater their long
term compatibility. - Fortunately, people tend to be attracted to
others who share their values and come from a
similar cultural background.
23Gendered Intimacy
- Generally, whereas men use intimacy to get sex,
women use sex to get intimacy. - It is partly related to male and female biology.
Men have a higher sex drive at younger ages,
while women have a higher sex drive at older
ages. - This is also due to socialization, which
encourages women to pursue intimacy while telling
men to be less intimate and more autonomous and
self-interested. - This means that men and women who have been
socialized into mainstream definitions of
masculine and feminine are likely to
experience love and marriage in different ways. - It also means that women are much more likely to
complain of the marriage as lacking in intimacy,
and this may lead to divorce.
24Gendered Intimacy
- Women tend to blend sexuality with emotional
intimacy men tend to separate sex and intimacy. - For women more than men, an argument will affect
her desire to have sex with her partner. - Marriage brings responsibilities that passion
alone cannot conquer, and passion itself is
affected by social performance. - Satisfying sexual relationships are dependent
upon satisfying social relationships, especially
for women. - When the quality of the husband-wife interaction
declines, the frequency and quality of sex tends
to decline as well. - The key to marital bliss is in the everyday
quality of spousal interaction. They must enjoy
each others company in rooms beyond the bedroom.
25Marriage
- Research suggests that romantic love involves a
high level of fantasy. People fall in love with
others for what they would like them to be not
as they really are. - Women, more than men, are socialized to fall in
love with the idea of marriage. Consequently
women tend to have higher expectations about
marriage, and are therefore more likely to become
disappointed with the reality of marriage. - In marriage, spouses must learn to be realistic
about their expectations of their partners. - There are several significant periods in a
marriage that involve re-negotiation of roles and
that many bring conflicts. - 1. The first baby.
- 2. When the last child leaves home.
26Problems of Childrearing
- Childrearing places special stresses on the
family. - 1. Economic stress. While children are an
economic asset in agrarian economies, they are an
economic liability in industrial economies. It
has become very expensive to raise a child. - 2. Social stress. Due to traditional gender
roles, the mother tends to lose much of her
social life because she bears primary
responsibility for parenting the child, and she
often becomes more dependent upon the man. - Women experience more role conflicts due to
conflicting expectations as a parent versus a
wage earner. Research suggests that women do
benefit from having roles outside the family,
however. This is because family stress can be
buffered by having enjoyable non-family roles.
This is called role buffering. - 3. Psychological stress. It is not uncommon for
men to feel jealous toward new babies and to feel
more personal stress as the breadwinner.
27Marriage in Later Life
- Today couples can expect to live into their mid
to late 70s. This is 20 years longer than 150
years ago. - By the age of 50, the children have typically
left home, leaving the husband and wife home
alone to readjust their relationship. - This can be stressful and it is not uncommon for
divorce to occur in this phase of marriage. They
may learn they have little in common other than
the kids. - This can also be a stressful time because
motherhood may have been the wifes master status
and she must now renegotiate her identity.
28Varieties of Family Life
- 1. Social Class.
- The lower the social class, the greater the
economic stresses and the more difficult to
sustain a family. - For this reason, people in the lower class are
less likely to marry, and once married, are more
likely to divorce than other social classes. - The lower the social class, the less nuclear and
more extended the family form is likely to be.
This is because extended families offer more
support for poor people. - The only exception involves the upper class,
where extended families are common in order to
promote in-group solidarity and to protect
in-group wealth. Rich people are expected to
marry other rich people and this helps sustain
extended family wealth. This is throw-back to the
aristocracies of old. - The family is our most adaptive institution, and
we adapt our families to specific conditions.
29Varieties of Family Life
- 2. Ethnicity and Race
- A. Hispanics (about 15 of the U.S. population)
- More emphasis on familism, which means loyalty
and duty to family. - Tend to lean toward extended families, partly due
to Hispanics being disproportionately poor. - Tend to support traditional rigid gender and
family roles that support patriarchy.
30Ethnicity and Race
- B. Blacks (about 13 of the U.S. population)
- Highest percentage of single mothers.
- Almost 50 of black families are headed by a
single mother, compared with about 14 among
whites. Female headed households are common among
the poor of all races. - The black family has been strongly shaped by the
legacy of racism and the poverty brought by
racism. - Blacks are three times more likely to be poor
than whites. - Average black household income is only 2/3rds
that of whites. - Blacks suffer from higher rates of unemployment,
partly because many live in the ghetto, where
unemployment is high.
31Blacks
- Blacks are less like to marry, and once married,
are more likely to divorce than whites. - Like white families, black families tend to be
nuclear in the middle class and extended in the
lower class. - Today, more than 1/3rd of all black children grow
up in poverty. - Yet there is remarkable strength in many poor
black families because extended family members
support each other. - It is practical for single mothers to rely
extensively upon her extended family supports for
help with day care, transportation, housing,
emotional support, and other vital needs.
32Black fertility rates
- The birth rate for black women has generally been
higher than for the rest of the population. - In 1996 there were 74 births per 1000 black
women, compared with 45 births per thousand for
the American population overall. - Black fertility peaked in 1989 at 91 births per
1000 black women. - The high fertility rate of poor black women has
been the focus of much debate, because the more
children a poor mother has, the greater the
economic stress.
33Why is the fertility rate higher among poor black
families?
- Education factors. Generally, the less educated,
the less likely to use birth control. Plus, our
popular culture is highly sexualized. - Emotional factors. Given American racism, sexism,
and classism, poor black women are not as well
respected in our society. Parenthood confers at
least some respect for the mother and it
produces the feeling of being productive in
society. It may also be the case that she wants
love, and she hopes her children will bring her
love. - Economic factors. She may hope that one of her
children will become affluent, so she thinks the
more babies she has the greater the chances. In
reality, the more babies she has, the more
economic stress she has. - Cultural factors. In the ghetto, it is not
uncommon (1) for her to see other girls having
more babies and to see it as normal behavior, and
(2) for young black men to feel pride by having
babies from different women. If he cant be a man
financially at least he can sire children to show
he is a real man. Commercial hip hop doesnt
help here.
34Gender Issues
- American culture promotes the idea that marriage
is more beneficial for women than for men. - This is a myth. The myth is related to
traditional gender role expectations that women
give up their jobs upon marriage and childbirth
to assume the role of full time mother. - The problem here is that it makes women dependent
upon men, and thus gives more power and authority
to men at the expense of gender equality. - Another problem is that it places all eggs in
the single basket of motherhood. Research
suggests that people feel more fulfilled when
they have a variety of productive roles.
35Gender Issues
- Research suggests that, contrary to myth,
marriage tends to be more beneficial for men than
women. - Married women report more illnesses and lower
levels of personal happiness than single women.
Women are more likely than men to feel trapped in
marriage. - Women tend to be socialized into unrealistically
high expectations about marriage, and patriarchy
takes its toll on women in every institution,
including marriage. - Married men report fewer illnesses and higher
levels of personal happiness than single men. - Men have been socialized into relatively lower
expectations about marriage. - Egalitarian marriages where the husband shares
with the housework are associated with the
highest levels of happiness, while patriarchal
marriages where the wife has a full time wage job
and also does the housework are associated with
the lowest levels of happiness.
36Gender Issues
- Today, American men do only about 1/3rd of the
housework compared with women. - This is better than it used to be, but it is
inherently unfair in many cases because most
women today have full time wage jobs. - This issue is complex. Men are socialized to not
be as clean-oriented as women. What is dirty is
in the eye of the beholder, and women are more
likely than men to perceive a dirty household. - A key issue is whether women accept the
relatively less amount of labor done by men. If
she doesnt, it often means conflict. - There are socialization implications for
future-parents here. Should boys be socialized
toward household chores like cleaning toilets
more? - Due to patriarchy, men have more leisure time
than women in context of their family
responsibilities. - This may create marital conflicts too.
37Family Problems - Divorce
- Americans have one of the highest marriage rates
in the world. Roughly 90 of all Americans
eventually marry. - But America also has the highest divorce rate in
the world. Today about 40-45 of American
marriages end up in divorce. - The divorce rate peaked in the early 1980s in the
high 40s percentage and has declined slightly
since then. - Among whites the divorce rate is just under 40,
while among blacks it is over 66. - Between 1890 and 1990 the divorce rate increased
by a factor of ten.
38What explains the high divorce rate?
- 1. Romantic love. Our cultures emphasis on
romantic love breeds unstable relationships. - 2. Increases in individualism and the
privatization of marriage. Americans spend less
time with their families today. We have become
more individualistic and privatized. The rise of
television and dual-earner families has made it
harder for spouses to connect. - 3. Women are less dependent on the wages of the
husband, making it easier for her to leave the
relationship. - 4. Children are more expensive and bring new
stresses that some couples did not anticipate. - 5. Divorce is no longer so stigmatized today
values are changing - and its easier to obtain a
divorce today. - 6. The American economy has become less stable
since 1972, bringing new economic stresses. - 7. The high re-marriage rate means that divorced
people can expect to find someone else.
39Who divorces? Divorce rates are higher for the
following categories
- Teenagers and younger people, more than middle
aged people. - The lower social classes, where economic stresses
are great. - Where marriage was due to unexpected pregnancy.
- Where there is less homogamy between the spouses,
or where the spouses sense they are incompatible
or fight a lot. - Where women have successful careers. Likewise,
where men prioritize their careers over marriage,
and his spouse is not economically dependent on
him. - Those who have already been through a divorce or
whose parents divorced. - People who move away from kinfolk and friends and
become more socially isolated. - People unable to cope with the loss of passion in
a marriage or where one or both partners is
immature or unfaithful.
40Problems of Divorce
- Divorce is not necessarily a problem. When
divorce is the consequence of abuse, it is the
solution to a problem. However, divorce usually
involves making difficult adjustments, especially
if kids are involved - 1. Emotional adjustments sadness, depression,
disappointment, sense of failure or loss, perhaps
hostility. - Generally women have better coping strategies
than men. Women are more likely to seek support
from friends, family and counselors. All else
being equal, it may take the average man twice as
long to recover (up to a year). - 2. Legal adjustments new legal burdens,
especially for estranged parents. - 3. Community adjustments Individuals must
redefine themselves and become single again.
Often friends divide up, favoring one or the
other partner. - 4. Economic adjustments women tend to suffer a
drop in living standards, while men tend to see a
rise in their living standards.
41Divorce Involving Parents
- More than half of all divorces involve parents
who must resolve child custody issues. - The traditional pattern is to award custody to
the mother, because women have been traditionally
viewed as the primary parent. - Recently a growing number of fathers have sought
custody, and now joint custody where both
parents retain child care responsibilities is
common. - Joint custody preserves a strong bond between
both parents and lessens the degree of hostility
between the spouses. However it is difficult if
one spouse moves away or the parents do not get
along with each other. - Where the mother gets custody and the father is
required to pay child support, there is a good
chance that the father will become delinquent
after about a year, especially if there is anger
or resentment by the father. Increasingly, the
state has stepped in to force payment. - Unpaid support contributes to the feminization of
poverty, where women are more likely to be poor
than men.
42Divorce Involving Parents
- Divorce brings emotional stresses, particularly
on fathers who are not given custody and on
children. - If the child is too young to remember, then the
divorce tends to be less traumatizing. If the
child is old enough to remember but not yet
mature, the divorce often brings long-term
trauma, and it is not uncommon for children to
blame themselves for the divorce. - These life changes are highly stressful in most
cases. Yet studies suggest that children seem to
fare better under divorce compared with staying
in a family characterized by a high level of
conflict and violence. - Divorces involving legal settlements imposed on
parents by judges in an antagonistic setting with
opposing attorneys often bring poor settlements
for one or both parties. - When divorce is mediated by a child custody
mediator, such as offered by neutral
organizations like United Way, the settlement is
more likely to be respected and honored by both
parents. (The lawyer merely carries out this
mediated agreement).
43Remarriage
- As the divorce rate in the U.S. increased, so did
the remarriage rate. Today more than 80 of those
who divorce will remarry. - Men are more likely to remarry than women.
- Remarriage often creates blended families
composed of children from different marriages. - Blended families must make special efforts to
establish new (in-group) family boundaries to
include the children. - Subjecting children to new, instant family
relationships is difficult and stressful. Blended
families are difficult to sustain due to these
new stresses.
44Family Violence
- The U.S. has the highest rate of family violence
among all industrial societies. - In 2005, more than 700,000 people were victims of
family violence. - 73 of the victims were women.
- Today, almost 1/3rd of all female murders are due
to family violence. - This compares with only 4 of male murders.
- Patriarchy has a severe effect on women.
Historically, wives were the property of the
husband and it was permissible for him to beat
her if she was disobedient.
45Family Violence
- Our society promotes the ideal image of family as
a source of haven, fun, and fulfillment. It also
promotes the family as sacred and private. - These images hide the reality of the family
experience, which usually falls short of its
ideal. - The American nuclear family is characterized by
high levels of emotional intensity between the
spouses, which is wonderful in context of love.
But it also helps explain American family
violence. Passion may quickly give way to violent
anger. - The American emphasis on romantic love, the
American love affair with alcohol, and the
American rat race of stressful living
contribute to our cultures high family violence
rate. And there are other factors too.
46Spousal Abuse
- The single most dreaded call by the police is the
domestic dispute call. Police are more likely
to be harmed by domestic disputes than any other
call. This is due to the emotional intensity of
these arguments. - Spouse abuse occurs in all social classes,
although it is more likely to occur in the most
stressed out social class the lower class. - Psychologists have identified a relationship
between stress and physical aggression. - Wherever there is chronic stress, there is a
greater likelihood of family abuse. - About one in six couples have at least some
violence in their relationship in any given year.
- Women are as likely as men to initiate violence.
However, - 1. Violence against men is often retaliatory, and
- 2. Women are more seriously harmed by men than
the other way around.
47Spousal Abuse Causes
- 1. Romance and passion create an atmosphere of
intensity. - 2. Psychological sense of feeling trapped or
caged in causes stress, which is linked to
aggressive behavior. - This sensation of feeling trapped may be caused
by a bad relationship, a bad job, a new baby,
health issues, financial stress, etc. - 3. Patriarchy. Women are devalued in patriarchal
societies, and patriarchy encourages male
authoritarianism. - In North Carolina at the beginning of the 21st
century, it was legal to rape your wife,
providing you shared the same roof. - 4. Traditional masculinity (related to
patriarchy) emphasizes brute power, aggression,
and dominance. - 5. Immaturity by the perpetrator.
- 6. The American society encourages aggressive
behavior. We are socialized into violent
action-movies and hip hop culture that celebrate
our gun culture. - 7. Alcohol Americas favorite drink creates
the Jekyll-Hyde syndrome. - 8. Family experiences growing up violence begets
violence, reminding us that family violence is
largely learned behavior. - 9. Social isolation. The private nuclear family
isolates and hides family violence. When friends
and extended family do not live nearby, violence
is more likely.
48Why doesnt she leave him?
- In the past, the law regarded domestic violence
as a private issue between the spouses. She had
few resources. - Even today, there are relatively few womens
shelters. In the Fall of 2007, one of the main
Charlotte womens shelters closed. - Traditionally, women have had few options. Even
today, most women remain in the abusive
relationship. Why? - She lacks sufficient family and wage resources to
get out - Her self-esteem tends to be very low
- she has become passive and tries to endure the
violence - She often feels she loves him and hopes he will
reform (often this means stop drinking) some day
- she feels she is dependent on him, perhaps
because they have children and she does not have
a good job or family resources - she may have tried to get away but lacked the
resources and ended up back with him again. After
that it is harder to take action.
49Child Abuse
- In 2005, there were 3 million reports of alleged
child abuse or neglect. - Roughly 1500 children die each year from child
abuse. - Child abuse is the ultimate taboo. This is
because it is a severe violation of trust and
power in a dependent relationship. - Children are dependents. They must depend on
their families to provide for them, and this
special power must not be abused. - Child abuse is both physical and emotional.
Children suffer deep and lasting scars - They may somehow blame themselves
- They learn to distrust others
- They have difficulty loving others
- They frequently abuse themselves with drugs,
prostitution, and other self-abusive behaviors.
50Who are the abusers?
- Child abuse is largely learned behavior.
- Roughly 58 of child abusers are women, almost
all of whom were themselves abused. - Incest, a special case of child abuse, involves
the sexual abuse of a child. About 90 of these
abusers are men, but they do not fall into easy
categories. - One common trait of child abuse is that the
abusers themselves were more likely to have been
abused when they were children. - Violent behavior within close family
relationships is typically learned behavior.
51Primary causes of non-incest child abuse
- 1. Stress, such as from feeling trapped in a
relationship, a constantly screaming child, a bad
job, feeling overworked or exhausted, etc. - 2. Authoritarianism. Often the child abuser
expects too much of the child and punishes them
for failing to meet their strict and overly-high
expectations. - 3. Immaturity.
- 4. Alcohol.
- 5. Learned via their own family experience.
- 6. Absence of family and other social supports.
52Conclusion
- Americans have high divorce and family violence
rates for reasons that relate to the social
structure itself. - The Americans are the only industrial democracy
that treats work and family life as two separate
spheres. They are not. If work is stressful, we
bring these stresses home and kick the dog.
American jobs are highly stressful and policy
makers provide fewer supports for U.S. families
compared with every other industrial democracy. - Americans are the only industrial democracy
without national health care, national day care
supports, 4-6 week vacations, and strong
anti-poverty welfare support programs. In this
country, the prevailing attitude is capitalist
self-interest. - There are other key factors too American
gun-culture, masculinity, romantic love,
hyper-individualism, and the American love affair
with alcohol all contribute to our family
problems.
53End