Title: From the Genealogy, section 13
1From the Genealogy, section 13
- That lambs dislike great birds of prey does not
seem strangeonly it gives no ground for
reproaching those birds of prey for bearing off
little lambs.
2From the Genealogy, section 13
- And if the lambs say among themselves these
birds of prey are evil and whoever is least like
a bird of prey, but rather its opposite, a
lambwould he not be good? there is no reason to
find fault with this institution of an ideal
3From the Genealogy, section 13
- except perhaps that the birds of prey might view
it a little ironically and say we dont
dislike them at all, these good little lambs we
even love them nothing is more tasty than a
tender lamb.
4From the Genealogy, section 13
- When the oppressed, downtrodden, outraged exhort
one another with the vengeful cunning of
impotence let us be different from the evil,
namely good! And he is good who does not
outrage, who harms nobody, who does not attack,
who does not requite, who leaves revenge to God,
who keeps himself hidden as we do, who avoids
evil and desires little from life, like us, the
patient, humble, and just
5From the Genealogy, section 13
- this, listened to calmly and without previous
bias, really amounts to no more than we weak
ones are, after all, weak it would be good if we
did nothing for which we are not strong enough
but this dry matter of fact, this prudence of the
lowest order which even insects possess (posing
as dead, when in great danger, so as not to do
too much), has, thanks to the counterfeit and
self-deception of impotence, clad itself in the
ostentatious garb
6From the Genealogy, section 13
- of the virtue of quiet, calm resignation, just as
if the weakness of the weakthat is to say, their
essence, their effects, their sole ineluctable,
irremovable realitywere a voluntary achievement,
willed, chosen, a deed, a meritorious act.
7From the Genealogy, section 14
- Would anyone like to take a look into the secret
of how ideals are made on earth?
8From the Genealogy, section 14
- Weakness is being lied into something
meritorious, no doubt of it, and impotence which
does not requite into goodness of heart
anxious lowliness into humility subjection to
those one hates into obedience.
9From the Genealogy, section 14
- The inoffensiveness of the weak man, even the
cowardice of which he has so much, his lingering
at the door, his being ineluctably compelled to
wait, here acquire flattering names, such as
patience, and are even called virtue itself
his inability for revenge is called unwillingness
to revenge, perhaps even forgiveness. They also
speak of loving ones enemiesand sweat as they
do so.
10From the Genealogy, section 14
- But enough! Enough! I cant take any more. Bad
air! This workshop were ideals are
manufacturedit seems to me it stinks of so many
lies.
11From the Genealogy, section 10
- The slave revolt in morality begins when
ressentiment itself becomes creative and gives
birth to values. While every noble morality
develops from a triumphant affirmation fo itself,
slave morality from the outset says No to what is
outside, what is different, what is not
itself and this No is its creative deed.
12From Beyond Good and Evil 228
- May I be forgiven the discovery that all moral
philosophy so far has been boring and a soporific
and that virtue has been impaired more for me by
its boring advocates than by anything else.
Consider, for example, the indefatigable,
inevitable British utilitarians, how they walk
clumsily and honorably in Benthams footsteps.
13From Beyond Good and Evil 228
- Ultimately they all want English morality to be
proved rightbecause this serves humanity best,
or the general utility, or the happiness of
the greatest numberno, the happiness of
England. With all their powers they want to
prove to themselves that the striving for English
happinessI mean comfort and fashion (and at best
a seat in Parliament) is indeed at the same time
the right way to virtue.
14From Beyond Good and Evil 228
- None of these ponderous herd animals with their
unquiet consciousness wants to know or even sense
that the general welfare is no goal, no ideal,
but only an emeticthat the demand for one
morality for all is detrimental for the higher
men, in short that there is an order of rank
between man and man.
15From Beyond Good and Evil 228
- They are a modest and thoroughly mediocre type of
man, these utilitarian Englishmen, and, as said
above, boring.
16From Beyond Good and Evil 225
- Whether it is hedonism or pessimism or
utilitarianismall these ways of thinking that
measure the value of things in accordance with
pleasure and pain are ways of thinking that
everyone conscious of creative powers and
artistic conscience will look down on not without
derision.
17From Beyond Good and Evil 225
- You want, if possibleand there is no more insane
if possibleto abolish suffering. And we? It
really seems that we would rather have it higher
and worse than ever. The discipline of
suffering, of great sufferingdo you not know
that only this discipline has created all
enhancements of man so far?
18From Beyond Good and Evil 225
- But to say it once more there are higher
problems than all problems of pleasure, pain, and
pity and every philosophy that stops with them
is a naivete.
19What implications do Nietzsches views have for
20What implications do Nietzsches views have for
- Hobbess social contract theory?
21What implications do Nietzsches views have for
- Lockes social contract theory?
22What implications do Nietzsches views have for
23What implications do Nietzsches views have for
24What implications do Nietzsches views have for
- Christianity?
- Blessed are the poor
- Blessed are the meek
- If someone strikes you on the right cheek, turn
to him the other also.
25From Genealogy of Morals 9
- But why are you talking about nobler ideals?
Let us stick to the facts the people have
wonor the slaves or the mob or the herd or
whatever you like to call them The masters
have been disposed of the morality of the common
man has won.
26From Genealogy of Morals 16
- The two opposing values good and bad, good and
evil have been engaged in a fearful struggle on
earth for thousands of years and though the
latter value has certainly been on top for a long
time, there are still places where the struggle
is as yet undecided.
27- What is the appropriate response to the
(wide-spread although not complete) victory of
slave morality?
28- One kind of response
- A recrudescence
- Nietzsche as offering a debunking explanation
that returns everyone to the original, master
morality.
29- Second kind of response
- The herd will stay the same, but the bird of prey
will learn once again to fly and swoop. - An esoteric morality, addressed only to the
special few.
30- Third kind of response
- Embrace the historical facts.
- Transcend the dichotomy of master and slave
morality. - Go beyond good and evil.
31From Genealogy essay 2, section 19
- The bad conscience is an illness, there is no
doubt about that, but an illness as pregnancy is
an illness.