Layer Management and MIBs Sections Report

1
Layer Management and MIBsSections Report
2
LM Comments summary

• 14 comments
• 7 editorial Not discussed since section editor
  absent
• 6 Technical non-binding
• 1 Technical binding
• 2 comments accepted
• 5 accepted-modified

3
Highlights

• Rename the MIB attributes in order to be
  consistent with other sections abbreviations
• Break the table that specifies the MIB and their
  description into a few tables to improve
  readability and clarity
• Generalize the primitives between the management
  and the MAC MIB attributes so they will cover all
  private primitives that were defined in other
  sections.

4
Annex E Comments summary

• 34 comments
• 11 editorial Not discussed since section editor
  absent
• 21 Technical non-binding
• 2 Technical binding
• 7 comments accepted
• 10 accepted-modified
• 4 rejected
• 2 withdrawn

5
Rejected Comments

• 427
• Add new table. Commenter was requested to
  resubmit a detailed comment and proposed
  resolution
• 40
• Change the index to Topology table. The proposed
  resolution doesnt improve the table structure
• 87
• MIB to support multiple ringlets. Wasnt
  addressed by the group
• 44
• Add a new object tote/deactivate the protection
  switching capability on SD. Alternatively, SD
  threshold can be set higher than SF.

6
Highlights

• Release the MIBs to the IETF after it will be
  completed
• Should the IEEE802.17 provide a separate ascii
  file of the MIB tables
• Incorporate references from the MIBs description
  to the relevant sections in the draft
• Add Total statistics tables to the MIB. OAM
  clause will determine optionally of the intervals
  vs. total statistics
• MIB attributes will follow changes in the drafts