Volker Spath, Germany Regis Thepot

1

2
Visions of the River and flood protection
approachesMirjam de Groot
Results Opinions on flood protection approaches
3
Visions of the River and flood protection
approachesMirjam de Groot
Results Visions of nature Human/nature
relationships
-0.24
-1.65
-0.59
-0.74
4
Visions of the River and flood protection
approachesMirjam de Groot
Results Leisure experience
5
Visions of the River and flood protection
approachesMirjam de Groot
Results place attachment Safety perception
Background variable
6
Ecological restoration and place attachment

• Martin Drenthen
• Radboud University Nijmegen
• Dept of Philosophy Science Studies. ISIS,
  Science Faculty

7
Sense of place v.2.0
Underneath the thin human layer wildness still
resides
8
Reconciling 1, 2 3 by respecting the genius of
place?

• Solution? ? palimpsest landscape
• respecting old and new layers
• community-based ecological restoration could even
  present a chance to revitalize and deepen our
  place-attachment and our attempts to invest
  meaning in these places
• or not?

9
?Premature reconciliation?

• Writer / activist Willem van Toorn
• ? Underlying cultural gap
• In new nature, man is a stranger, merely a
  visitor to his own landscape and no longer a
  resident for whom the signs of the land are food
  for the spirit.
• The cultural landscape must be protected
  against a light-hearted kind of postmodern
  thinking in which history is just a grab bag...

10
4. Super-modernity and non-places

• Airport is an archetypical non-place
• All airports are alike
• No one is really present
• Everyone is just passing through
• Augé mentions other nonplaces places of
  memory
• especially designed to evoke certain feelings or
  memories
• meanings projected upon the landscape
• in constant need of translation and explanation
  by experts

Overabundance of land-signs produced by
expert-visitors
11
New interpretation New nature as a place of
otherness
Wouter Helmer we should conceive new nature as
an insane oasis, a place where we can escape
from the all-too-human overabundance of societal
orders, regulations, and symbolizations of place
here we can again be confronted with the
not-yet-symbolized or humanized Paradox we have
inscribed this non-symbolic order ourselves!
? A killing objection?
12
Evolution of river management up to integral
and beyond

• Reinier de Nooij and Menno Straatsma, Radboud
  University Nijmegen and University of Utrecht.

13
(No Transcript)
14
(No Transcript)
15
vMeme history in the Netherlands
16
Content of integral river management
17
Levels of participation and interactional issue
framing in a water area planning process

• Greet François1, Art Dewulf2, Tharsi Taillieu1
• 1 K.U.Leuven - Work, Organisational and Personnel
  Psychology
• 2 Wageningen University - Public Administration
  and Policy Group
• Freude-am-Fluss Conference, Nijmegen, 22-24 Oct
  2008

18
(No Transcript)
19
(No Transcript)
20
Interactional issue framing

• Issue framing
• how people make sense of issues
• Interactional approach
• negotiating meaning
• enacting discourse
• dealing with differences
• Focus on
• how people interactively frame the issues in the
  problem doman
• quality of the discussion and decision
• how the different stakes and interdependence
  between fruit and cattle farmers are dealt with
  in the discussions

21
Framing patterns in the planning process

• Sequence
• frame selling
• frame selling frame filling
• frame selling frame filling frame negotiation
• Importance of interaction setting
• Importance of development over time
• But
• Break-out groups in the first meeting
• Importance of interaction setting